Social determinants of Health Research Center, Tabriz University of Medical sciences, Tabriz, Iran.
School of Nursing and Midwifery, Faculty of Health Sciences, Australian Catholic University, Sydney, Australia.
BMC Pregnancy Childbirth. 2022 Oct 5;22(1):751. doi: 10.1186/s12884-022-05078-z.
The prevalence of cesarean birth in Iran is very high. Having a negative childbirth experience is one of the reasons that primiparous women provide to prefer caesarean birth over a vaginal birth. This study is aimed to understand women's perspective on what determines a positive or negative birth experience for them.
This qualitative study is a part a mixed method study that was conducted among primiparous women with a previous vaginal birth experience. The purpose of the main study was to develop a guideline based on Iranian primiparous women's birth experiences. The quantitative phase of the study was a cross-sectional study where women's childbirth experiences was measured in a survey via the Childbirth Experience Questionnaire-2. In the qualitative part of the study, women were invited for an in-depth interview via a random stratified sampling method based on their childbirth mean score (women with 10% of the upper bound score which indicated a positive birth experience and 10% of the lower bound indicating negative birth experience, n = 17). Conventional content analysis was used for data analysis.
We extracted three main themes: (a) "Internal control", (b) "External control", and (c) "Support". Possessing internal control, having a balanced external control to feel cared and feeling supported were the main reasons for women to feel positive about their birth experiences. Whereas, loss of internal control, imbalanced external control and unsupportive environment were related to their negative childbirth experiences.
Considering that women's sense of control, the care and support that they receive can influence their childbirth experiences, there is a need for changing maternity policies and practices to highlight the importance of a woman-centred care to create a pleasant, respectful and positive memory for primirparous women who experience normal vaginal births.
伊朗的剖宫产率非常高。对初产妇来说,负面的分娩体验是她们选择剖宫产而不是阴道分娩的原因之一。本研究旨在了解女性对决定她们分娩体验是积极还是消极的因素的看法。
这是一项混合方法研究的一部分,该研究是在有阴道分娩经验的初产妇中进行的。主要研究的目的是根据伊朗初产妇的分娩经验制定一个指南。研究的定量阶段是一项横断面研究,通过使用分娩体验问卷-2 对女性的分娩体验进行测量。在研究的定性部分,通过随机分层抽样方法,根据产妇的分娩平均得分邀请女性进行深入访谈(得分最高的 10%的产妇表示有积极的分娩体验,得分最低的 10%表示有消极的分娩体验,n=17)。采用常规内容分析法进行数据分析。
我们提取了三个主题:(a)“内部控制”,(b)“外部控制”和(c)“支持”。拥有内部控制、感到被关心和得到支持是女性对分娩体验感到积极的主要原因。而失去内部控制、外部控制不平衡和缺乏支持的环境则与她们的负面分娩体验有关。
考虑到女性的控制感、她们所获得的关怀和支持会影响她们的分娩体验,需要改变产时政策和实践,强调以妇女为中心的护理的重要性,为经历正常阴道分娩的初产妇创造愉快、尊重和积极的记忆。