Jordan Institute for Families, School of Social Work, Collaborative for Maternal and Infant Health School of Medicine, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, North Carolina, USA.
Office for Equity, Diversity and Inclusion, Department of Clinical Medicine, University of California San Diego Health, San Diego, California, USA.
Health Serv Res. 2022 Dec;57(6):1396-1407. doi: 10.1111/1475-6773.14082. Epub 2022 Oct 17.
To understand how Black and Native American women with chronic conditions experience reproductive health care and identify patient-centered strategies to improve care.
We held a series of virtual focus groups between February 2021 and December 2021 with 34 women who self-identified as Black or Native American, were of childbearing age, had one or more chronic conditions, and lived in North Carolina.
This qualitative, community-engaged study reviewed notes, video recordings, and graphic illustrations from the focus group sessions. Content analysis was used to iteratively identify themes. Emerging themes were reviewed by community and patient partners.
There were six thematic areas that emerged on the current state of reproductive health care for people with chronic conditions: (1) lack of trust in health care providers and institutions, (2) lack of health care provider knowledge, (3) uncoordinated care, (4) need for self-advocacy, (5) provider bias, and (6) mental health strain from coping. Six approaches for care improvement emerged: (1) build on models of coordinated health care services from other conditions to design more comprehensive care clinics, (2) involve care coordinators or navigators, (3) improve educational materials for patients, (4) train clinicians to increase their capacity to be trustworthy and provide quality, equitable, person-focused care, (5) design scripts to improve clinicians' ability to talk with women about infertility, miscarriage, infant loss, and (6) all interventions and research should be co-designed to address patient priorities.
Engaging Black and Native American patient partners with chronic conditions in research planning is feasible, necessary, and beneficial using methods that support connection, respect, and bi-directional learning. Patient partners defined actionable strategies to improve reproductive care and wellness including comprehensive care clinics with patient navigators, trust-enhancing interventions, and better provision of reproductive health related education.
了解慢性疾病黑人及美国原住民女性的生殖健康护理体验,并确定以患者为中心的改善护理的策略。
我们于 2021 年 2 月至 2021 年 12 月期间,与 34 名自认为是黑人或美国原住民、处于生育年龄、患有一种或多种慢性病且居住在北卡罗来纳州的女性进行了一系列虚拟焦点小组讨论。
这项定性、社区参与的研究回顾了焦点小组会议的笔记、视频记录和图表说明。采用内容分析法对主题进行了迭代识别。社区和患者合作伙伴对新出现的主题进行了审查。
目前慢性疾病患者生殖健康护理的现状存在以下 6 个主题领域:(1)对医疗保健提供者和医疗机构缺乏信任;(2)医疗保健提供者知识不足;(3)护理不协调;(4)需要自我倡导;(5)提供者偏见;(6)应对压力导致心理健康受损。改善护理的方法有 6 种:(1)借鉴其他疾病的协调护理服务模式,设计更全面的护理诊所;(2)配备护理协调员或导航员;(3)改进患者教育材料;(4)培训临床医生,提高他们值得信赖并提供优质、公平、以人为本的护理能力;(5)设计脚本,提高临床医生与女性谈论不孕、流产、婴儿死亡的能力;(6)所有干预措施和研究都应共同设计,以解决患者的首要问题。
通过支持联系、尊重和双向学习的方法,让患有慢性疾病的黑人及美国原住民患者合作伙伴参与研究规划是可行、必要和有益的。患者合作伙伴确定了改善生殖护理和健康的可操作策略,包括配备患者导航员的综合护理诊所、增强信任的干预措施以及更好地提供生殖健康相关教育。