Thornton Madeline, Ishoso Daniel, Lokangaka Adrien, Berkelhamer Sara, Bauserman Melissa, Eilevstjønn Joar, Iyer Pooja, Kamath-Rayne Beena D, Mafuta Eric, Myklebust Helge, Patterson Janna, Tshefu Antoinette, Bose Carl, Patterson Jackie K
Department of Pediatrics, University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill, Chapel Hill, NC, United States.
School of Public Health, University of Kinshasa, Kinshasa, Democratic Republic of Congo.
Front Pediatr. 2022 Sep 29;10:943496. doi: 10.3389/fped.2022.943496. eCollection 2022.
900,000 newborns die from respiratory depression each year; nearly all of these deaths occur in low- and middle-income countries. Deaths from respiratory depression are reduced by evidence-based resuscitation. Electronic heart rate monitoring provides a sensitive indicator of the neonate's status to inform resuscitation care, but is infrequently used in low-resource settings. In a recent trial in the Democratic Republic of the Congo, midwives used a low-cost, battery-operated heart rate meter (NeoBeat) to continuously monitor heart rate during resuscitations. We explored midwives' perceptions of NeoBeat including its utility and barriers and facilitators to use.
After a 20-month intervention in which midwives from three facilities used NeoBeat during resuscitations, we surveyed midwives and conducted focus group discussions (FGDs) regarding the incorporation of NeoBeat into clinical care. FGDs were conducted in Lingala, the native language, then transcribed and translated from Lingala to French to English. We analyzed data by: (1) coding of transcripts using Nvivo, (2) comparison of codes to identify patterns in the data, and (3) grouping of codes into categories by two independent reviewers, with final categories determined by consensus.
Each midwife from Facility A used NeoBeat on an estimated 373 newborns, while each midwife at facilities B and C used NeoBeat an average 24 and 47 times, respectively. From FGDs with 30 midwives, we identified five main categories of perceptions and experiences regarding the use of NeoBeat: (1) Providers' initial skepticism evolved into pride and a belief that NeoBeat was essential to resuscitation care, (2) Providers viewed NeoBeat as enabling their resuscitation and increasing their capacity, (3) NeoBeat helped providers identify flaccid newborns as liveborn, leading to hope and the perception of saving of lives, (4) Challenges of use of NeoBeat included cleaning, charging, and insufficient quantity of devices, and (5) Providers desired to continue using the device and to expand its use beyond resuscitation and their own facilities.
Midwives perceived that NeoBeat enabled their resuscitation practices, including assisting them in identifying non-breathing newborns as liveborn. Increasing the quantity of devices per facility and developing systems to facilitate cleaning and charging may be critical for scale-up.
每年有90万新生儿死于呼吸抑制;几乎所有这些死亡都发生在低收入和中等收入国家。循证复苏可减少呼吸抑制导致的死亡。电子心率监测为新生儿状况提供了一个敏感指标,以指导复苏护理,但在资源匮乏地区很少使用。在刚果民主共和国最近的一项试验中,助产士使用了一种低成本、电池供电的心率计(NeoBeat)在复苏过程中持续监测心率。我们探讨了助产士对NeoBeat的看法,包括其效用以及使用的障碍和促进因素。
在一项为期20个月的干预中,来自三个机构的助产士在复苏过程中使用NeoBeat,之后我们对助产士进行了调查,并就将NeoBeat纳入临床护理进行了焦点小组讨论(FGD)。FGD用当地语言林加拉语进行,然后转录并从林加拉语翻译成法语再到英语。我们通过以下方式分析数据:(1)使用Nvivo对转录本进行编码,(2)比较编码以识别数据中的模式,(3)由两名独立评审员将编码分组为类别,最终类别通过共识确定。
机构A的每位助产士估计在373名新生儿身上使用了NeoBeat,而机构B和C的每位助产士平均分别使用了24次和47次。在与30名助产士进行的FGD中,我们确定了关于使用NeoBeat的五个主要看法和经验类别:(1)提供者最初的怀疑演变成了自豪,并相信NeoBeat对复苏护理至关重要,(2)提供者认为NeoBeat有助于他们进行复苏并提高了他们的能力,(3)NeoBeat帮助提供者将软弱无力的新生儿识别为活产儿,带来了希望并产生了挽救生命的感觉,(4)使用NeoBeat的挑战包括清洁、充电以及设备数量不足,(5)提供者希望继续使用该设备,并将其使用范围扩大到复苏之外以及他们自己的机构之外。
助产士认为NeoBeat有助于他们的复苏实践,包括帮助他们将无呼吸的新生儿识别为活产儿。增加每个机构的设备数量并开发便于清洁和充电的系统对于扩大规模可能至关重要。