Kaluwa Catherine, Oduma Jemimah, Abdirahman Faduma Abdullahi, Kitoga Byalungwa Kyotos, Opondoh Angela A, Muchibi John, Bagnol Brigitte, Rosenbaum Marieke, Onchaga Sylvia, Stanley Meghan, Amuguni Janetrix Hellen
Department of Veterinary Anatomy and Physiology, University of Nairobi, Nairobi P.O. Box 30197-00100, Kenya.
Department of Animal Production, University of Nairobi, Nairobi P.O. Box 29053-00625, Kenya.
Vaccines (Basel). 2022 Nov 4;10(11):1868. doi: 10.3390/vaccines10111868.
Livestock diseases are a major barrier to productivity for both male and female livestock keepers in Africa. In Kenya, two of the most devastating livestock diseases are Newcastle Disease (ND) in poultry and Contagious Caprine Pleuropneumonia (CCPP) in goats. Female livestock keepers tend to own more small ruminants (goats, sheep, etc.) and poultry and their livelihoods are adversely affected if their herds are not vaccinated against these diseases. Livestock farming has gender specific challenges and opportunities, with implications for the empowerment of women smallholder farmers, their household well-being, food security, and livelihoods. There is a need to estimate the level to which women benefit personally, socially, and economically from keeping livestock, yet there are very few studies that can measure if livestock production does in fact empower women smallholder livestock farmers. This study was done to examine linkages between women's empowerment and access and control over livestock products and vaccines. The Women Empowerment in Livestock Index (WELI) tool, which was customized to include questions on livestock vaccine access, was used to capture baseline data on empowerment scores for women in Machakos county, Kenya, prior to implementation of animal health and vaccine test models. In total, 400 participants were surveyed in two wards of Machakos County, Kola and Kalama, which were purposively selected. Women's empowerment was mapped to three domains (3DE): intrinsic agency (power within), instrumental agency (power to), and collective agency (power with) measured against adequacy in 13 indicators. Our results indicate that the household structure (female headed or dual headed household), age of respondents and number of members in a household influence the adequacy score. Work balance was the most significant negative contributor to women's disempowerment. Women contributed the most to livestock productive activities and attained adequacy in this area compared to men, directly impacting the WELI score. Women smallholder livestock farmers report low CCPP and ND vaccination rates, minimal knowledge on livestock diseases, a lack of access to cold chain storage and rarely visited veterinarians. The WELI score was 0.81 indicating a high level of empowerment for women in this community compared to men leading us to conclude that the overall WELI score was not an accurate indicator of women's empowerment in Machakos County. However, the decomposability of the index allows us to disaggregate the drivers of change and to examine how individual indicators contribute to disempowerment.
牲畜疾病是非洲男女牲畜饲养者提高生产力的主要障碍。在肯尼亚,两种最具毁灭性的牲畜疾病是家禽中的新城疫(ND)和山羊中的传染性胸膜肺炎(CCPP)。女性牲畜饲养者往往拥有更多的小型反刍动物(山羊、绵羊等)和家禽,如果她们的畜群没有接种这些疾病的疫苗,她们的生计就会受到不利影响。畜牧业存在特定性别的挑战和机遇,对增强女性小农户的权能、她们家庭的福祉、粮食安全和生计都有影响。有必要估计女性在饲养牲畜方面个人、社会和经济上的受益程度,但很少有研究能够衡量牲畜生产是否真的增强了女性小农户牲畜饲养者的权能。本研究旨在探讨女性赋权与获取和控制牲畜产品及疫苗之间的联系。在实施动物健康和疫苗测试模型之前,使用了针对包括牲畜疫苗获取问题进行定制的牲畜领域女性赋权指数(WELI)工具,来获取肯尼亚马查科斯县女性赋权得分的基线数据。总共在马查科斯县的两个选区科拉和卡拉马进行了调查,这两个选区是经过有目的选择的,共有400名参与者。女性赋权被映射到三个领域(3DE):内在能动性(内在力量)、工具性能动性(行动力量)和集体能动性(协同力量),并根据13项指标的充分程度进行衡量。我们的结果表明,家庭结构(女性户主或夫妻双方户主家庭)、受访者年龄和家庭中的成员数量会影响充分得分。工作平衡是导致女性权能被削弱的最显著负面因素。与男性相比,女性对牲畜生产活动的贡献最大,并且在这一领域达到了充分程度,这直接影响了WELI得分。女性小农户牲畜饲养者报告称,CCPP和ND疫苗接种率较低,对牲畜疾病的了解极少,无法使用冷链储存,而且很少见到兽医。WELI得分为0.81,表明与男性相比,该社区女性的赋权水平较高,这使我们得出结论,总体WELI得分并不是马查科斯县女性赋权的准确指标。然而,该指数的可分解性使我们能够分解变化驱动因素,并研究各个指标如何导致权能被削弱。