Jensen Monica, Askeland Ingunn Rangul, Bjørknes Ragnhild
Betanien Hospital, Bergen, Norway.
Faculty of Psychology, University of Bergen, Bergen, Norway.
Front Psychol. 2022 Dec 5;13:1019739. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2022.1019739. eCollection 2022.
Assessing minors with harmful sexual behavior (HSB) is a complex and sensitive task. The AIM3 Assessment Model was developed to assist practitioners with information collection and HSB evaluations.
In this study, we explore the interrater reliability and the practitioners' experience with the AIM3.
The multidisciplinary sample ( = 56) was recruited in Norway. The participants' mean age is 43.2 years (SD 9.5). The sample is 79% female and 21% male. Mean years of experience is 17.6 years (SD 9.5).
The participants used the Norwegian version of the AIM3 to score three case vignettes. A survey containing questions about competence and experience was filled out. We used the intraclass correlation coefficient (ICC) to estimate interrater reliability as well as descriptive statistics to show experience.
The estimated ICC for overall AIM3 factors is 0.547 (95% CI = 0.471, 0.634); for domain scores, the estimated ICC is 0.697 (95% CI = 0.548, 0.852). Both are in the moderate range. The majority of the participants reported that they will probably use the AIM3 in the future and that their experience with the AIM3 was highly useful with, for example, empirically informed decision-making and for intervention and safety planning.
The moderate ICC results and the sample's generally positive experience with the AIM3 may indicate further usefulness in a Norwegian multidisciplinary setting. We provide recommendations on how the AIM3 and similar HSB assessments can be further evaluated and developed.
评估有有害性行为(HSB)的未成年人是一项复杂且敏感的任务。AIM3评估模型的开发旨在帮助从业者进行信息收集和HSB评估。
在本研究中,我们探讨了评分者间信度以及从业者对AIM3的使用体验。
多学科样本(n = 56)招募自挪威。参与者的平均年龄为43.2岁(标准差9.5)。样本中79%为女性,21%为男性。平均工作经验为17.6年(标准差9.5)。
参与者使用挪威语版的AIM3对三个病例 vignettes进行评分。填写了一份包含有关能力和经验问题的调查问卷。我们使用组内相关系数(ICC)来估计评分者间信度,并使用描述性统计来展示经验。
AIM3总体因素的估计ICC为0.547(95%置信区间 = 0.471, 0.634);对于领域得分,估计ICC为0.697(95%置信区间 = 0.548, 0.852)。两者均处于中等范围。大多数参与者报告称他们未来可能会使用AIM3,并且他们对AIM3的体验在例如基于实证的决策制定以及干预和安全规划方面非常有用。
中等的ICC结果以及样本对AIM3普遍积极的体验可能表明其在挪威多学科背景下具有进一步的实用性。我们就如何进一步评估和开发AIM3及类似的HSB评估提供了建议。