Center for Infectious Disease and Nursing Innovation, Johns Hopkins University School of Nursing, Baltimore, MD, United States.
Department of Epidemiology, Mailman School of Public Health, Columbia University, New York, NY, United States.
Front Public Health. 2023 Jan 12;10:1087138. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2022.1087138. eCollection 2022.
A majority of low-income (LIC) and lower-middle-income countries (LMIC) were unable to achieve at least 10% population coverage during initial vaccine rollouts, despite the rapid development of the coronavirus disease 2019 (COVID-19) vaccines. Nearly three years into this pandemic, evaluating the impact of inequities in vaccine access, uptake, and availability is long overdue. We hypothesized that a delay in receiving COVID-19 vaccines was associated with an increased toll on cumulative cases and mortality. Furthermore, this relationship was modified by the size of a country's economy.
We performed an ecological study assessing these relationships, in which a country's economic standing was assessed by world bank income classification, gross domestic product based on the purchasing power parity (GDP PPP) per capita category, and crude GDP PPP.
Countries with the smallest economies reported first vaccination much later than larger economies on all three rankings, as much as 100 days longer. Among low-income countries, a one-day increase until the first vaccination was associated with a 1.92% (95% CI: 0.100, 3.87) increase in cumulative cases when compared to high-income countries ( = 0.0395) when adjusting for population size, median age, and testing data availability. Similarly, among the lowest GDP PPP countries a one-day increase until the first vaccination was associated with a 2.73% (95% CI: 0.100, 5.44) increase in cumulative cases when compared to the highest GDP PPP countries ( = 0.0415). When modeling cumulative mortality, effects in the same direction and magnitude were observed, albeit statistically non-significant.
Economic standing modified the effects of delayed access to COVID-19 vaccination on cumulative cases and mortality, in which LMICs tended to fare worse in outcomes than high-income countries despite the eventual rollout of vaccines. These findings highlight the importance of prioritizing equitable and timely access to COVID-19 vaccines across all countries, irrespective of economic size. Future studies should examine the impacts that vaccine inequities had on local transmission dynamics.
尽管 2019 年冠状病毒病(COVID-19)疫苗发展迅速,但大多数低收入(LIC)和中低收入国家(LMIC)在最初的疫苗推广中未能实现至少 10%的人口覆盖。在这场大流行近三年后,评估疫苗获取、接种和供应方面的不平等所带来的影响早已是当务之急。我们假设,延迟接种 COVID-19 疫苗与累计病例和死亡率的增加有关。此外,这种关系还受到一个国家经济规模的影响。
我们进行了一项生态研究,评估了这些关系,其中一个国家的经济地位通过世界银行收入分类、基于购买力平价(PPP)的人均国内生产总值(GDP PPP)类别和粗 GDP PPP 来评估。
在所有三种排名中,经济体最小的国家报告的首次接种时间都比更大的经济体晚得多,最长可达 100 天。在低收入国家中,与高收入国家相比(当调整人口规模、中位数年龄和检测数据可用性时, = 0.0395),首次接种前每增加一天与累计病例增加 1.92%(95%CI:0.100,3.87)相关;同样,在 GDP PPP 最低的国家中,与 GDP PPP 最高的国家相比(当调整人口规模、中位数年龄和检测数据可用性时, = 0.0415),首次接种前每增加一天与累计病例增加 2.73%(95%CI:0.100,5.44)相关。在对累计死亡率进行建模时,观察到了同样方向和大小的影响,但统计学上不显著。
经济地位改变了延迟获得 COVID-19 疫苗接种对累计病例和死亡率的影响,其中尽管最终推出了疫苗,但中低收入国家的结果比高收入国家差。这些发现强调了在所有国家中优先考虑公平和及时获得 COVID-19 疫苗的重要性,而不论其经济规模如何。未来的研究应研究疫苗不平等对当地传播动态的影响。