Faculty of Education, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Department of Psychology, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong SAR, China.
Sci Rep. 2023 Jan 30;13(1):1704. doi: 10.1038/s41598-023-28426-1.
Using background music (BGM) during learning is a common behavior, yet whether BGM can facilitate or hinder learning remains inconclusive and the underlying mechanism is largely an open question. This study aims to elucidate the effect of self-selected BGM on reading task for learners with different characteristics. Particularly, learners' reading task performance, metacognition, and eye movements were examined, in relation to their personal traits including language proficiency, working memory capacity, music experience and personality. Data were collected from a between-subject experiment with 100 non-native English speakers who were randomly assigned into two groups. Those in the experimental group read English passages with music of their own choice played in the background, while those in the control group performed the same task in silence. Results showed no salient differences on passage comprehension accuracy or metacognition between the two groups. Comparisons on fine-grained eye movement measures reveal that BGM imposed heavier cognitive load on post-lexical processes but not on lexical processes. It was also revealed that students with higher English proficiency level or more frequent BGM usage in daily self-learning/reading experienced less cognitive load when reading with their BGM, whereas students with higher working memory capacity (WMC) invested more mental effort than those with lower WMC in the BGM condition. These findings further scientific understanding of how BGM interacts with cognitive tasks in the foreground, and provide practical guidance for learners and learning environment designers on making the most of BGM for instruction and learning.
在学习过程中使用背景音乐(BGM)是一种常见的行为,但背景音乐是否能促进或阻碍学习的效果仍然没有定论,其潜在的机制在很大程度上仍是一个悬而未决的问题。本研究旨在阐明自定背景音乐对具有不同特征的学习者阅读任务的影响。具体而言,我们考察了学习者的阅读任务表现、元认知和眼动,以及他们的个人特质,包括语言熟练程度、工作记忆容量、音乐经验和个性。研究数据来自一项有 100 名非英语母语者参与的被试间实验,他们被随机分配到两个组。实验组在阅读英语文章时,背景音乐由他们自己选择,而对照组则在安静的环境中完成相同的任务。结果表明,两组在阅读理解准确性或元认知方面没有显著差异。对精细眼动测量的比较表明,背景音乐对词汇后加工过程施加了更大的认知负荷,但对词汇加工过程没有影响。研究还表明,英语水平较高或在日常自学/阅读中更频繁使用背景音乐的学生,在使用背景音乐阅读时,认知负荷较小,而工作记忆容量(WMC)较高的学生比 WMC 较低的学生在背景音乐条件下投入更多的心理努力。这些发现进一步科学地理解了背景音乐如何与 foreground 中的认知任务相互作用,并为学习者和学习环境设计者提供了实用的指导,以充分利用背景音乐进行教学和学习。