Applied Research Laboratory, Pen State University, University Park, State College, PA, United States of America.
Departments of Political Science and African American Studies, Penn State University, University Park, State College, PA, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2023 Feb 2;18(2):e0274470. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0274470. eCollection 2023.
We derive a simple asymptotic approximation for the long-run case fatality rate of COVID-19 (alpha and delta variants) and show that these estimations are highly correlated to the interaction between US State median age and projected US unemployment rate (Adj. r2 = 60%). We contrast this to the high level of correlation between point (instantaneous) estimates of per state case fatality rates and the interaction of median age, population density and current unemployment rates (Adj. r2 = 50.2%). To determine whether this is caused by a "race effect," we then analyze unemployment, race, median age and population density across US states and show that adding the interaction of African American population and unemployment explains 53.5% of the variance in COVID case fatality rates for the alpha and delta variants when considering instantaneous case fatality rate. Interestingly, when the asymptotic case fatality rate is used, the dependence on the African American population disappears, which is consistent with the fact that in the long-run COVID does not discriminate on race, but may discriminate on access to medical care which is highly correlated to employment in the US. The results provide further evidence of the impact inequality can have on case fatality rates in COVID-19 and the impact complex social, health and economic factors can have on patient survival.
我们推导出了 COVID-19(阿尔法和德尔塔变体)长期病死率的简单渐近近似值,并表明这些估计值与美国各州中位年龄与预测的美国失业率之间的相互作用高度相关(调整后的 r2 = 60%)。相比之下,各州病死率的点(瞬时)估计值与中位年龄、人口密度和当前失业率之间的相互作用高度相关(调整后的 r2 = 50.2%)。为了确定这是否是由“种族效应”引起的,我们分析了美国各州的失业率、种族、中位年龄和人口密度,并表明在考虑瞬时病死率时,当考虑到瞬时病死率时,将非裔美国人人口与失业率的相互作用加入到 COVID 病死率中,可以解释阿尔法和德尔塔变体的 COVID 病死率的 53.5%。有趣的是,当使用渐近病死率时,对非裔美国人人口的依赖就消失了,这与 COVID 在长期内不歧视种族的事实是一致的,但可能会因医疗保健的获取而产生歧视,而医疗保健的获取与美国的就业高度相关。研究结果进一步证明了不平等对 COVID-19 病死率的影响,以及复杂的社会、健康和经济因素对患者生存率的影响。