Division of Plastic and Reconstructive Surgery, The Warren Alpert Medical School of Brown University, Providence, RI, USA.
Cleft Palate Craniofac J. 2024 Jul;61(7):1228-1232. doi: 10.1177/10556656231154843. Epub 2023 Feb 6.
This study aims to analyze the readability of online craniosynostosis materials from the perspective of a caregiver, and to assess if readability levels conform to recommendations by the American Medical Association (AMA) and National Institutes of Health (NIH).
This is a cross-sectional investigation in which an internet search was conducted simulating the search terms of a caregiver of a patient with craniosynostosis. The first three pages of resulting records were calculated for comprehension ease using validated readability indices. Records were also classified by author type, including hospital system, national health organization, academic journal, and other.
Flesch-Kincaid Reading Grade Level, Gunning fog Index, SMOG Index, and Coleman Liau Index.
Thirty records were identified for which the mean readability level was 12.8 ± 2.6 grade levels (range, 7.6-15.9). There were no significant differences in mean readability across readability indices or author type. None of the thirty records met levels recommended by the AMA or NIH and were 6.8 grade levels above these guidelines on average.
Online material pertaining to craniosynostosis is written, on average, at the reading level of a first-year undergraduate student. The AMA and NIH recommend that articles be written at approximately a sixth-grade reading level to promote comprehension. Therefore, there is significant room for improvement of current online materials. Authors should consider consulting publicly available guides in preparing future resources.
本研究旨在从照顾者的角度分析颅缝早闭相关的在线资料的易读性,并评估其可读性水平是否符合美国医学协会(AMA)和美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)的建议。
这是一项横断面研究,通过模拟颅缝早闭患者照顾者的搜索词进行互联网搜索。使用经过验证的可读性指标来计算前 3 页记录的理解难易程度。同时根据作者类型对记录进行分类,包括医院系统、国家卫生组织、学术期刊和其他。
Flesch-Kincaid 阅读水平等级、Gunning fog 指数、SMOG 指数和 Coleman-Liau 指数。
共确定了 30 份记录,其平均可读性水平为 12.8±2.6 年级(范围为 7.6-15.9)。在可读性指标或作者类型方面,平均可读性没有显著差异。这 30 份记录中没有一份符合 AMA 或 NIH 的推荐水平,平均比这些指南高出 6.8 个年级。
颅缝早闭相关的在线资料的平均写作水平为一年级本科生的阅读水平。AMA 和 NIH 建议文章的写作水平应大约为六年级阅读水平,以促进理解。因此,当前在线资料有很大的改进空间。作者在准备未来资源时应考虑咨询公共可用的指南。