Koo Hyunjin J, Piff Paul K, Shariff Azim F
University of California, Irvine, USA.
The University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada.
Soc Psychol Personal Sci. 2023 Apr;14(3):333-341. doi: 10.1177/19485506221098921. Epub 2022 Jun 27.
Americans venerate rags-to-riches stories. Here we show that people view those who rich more positively than those rich and expect the Became Rich to be more sympathetic toward social welfare (Studies 1a and b). However, we also find that these intuitions are misguided. Surveys of wealthy individuals (Studies 2a and b) reveal that, compared with the Born Rich, the Became Rich perceive improving one's socioeconomic conditions as less difficult, which, in turn, predicts less empathy for the poor, less perceived sacrifices by the poor, more internal attributions for poverty, and less support for redistribution. Corroborating this, imagining having experienced upward mobility (vs. beginning and staying at the top) causes people to view such mobility as less difficult, reducing empathy and support for those failing to move up (Study 3). These findings suggest that becoming rich may shift views about the poor in ways that run counter to common intuitions and cultural assumptions.
美国人崇尚白手起家的故事。我们在此表明,人们对那些变得富有的人的看法比对天生富有的人更积极,并期望变得富有的人对社会福利更有同情心(研究1a和1b)。然而,我们也发现这些直觉是错误的。对富人群体的调查(研究2a和2b)显示,与天生富有的人相比,变得富有的人认为改善自己的社会经济状况不那么困难,这反过来又预示着对穷人的同情心更少,对穷人所做牺牲的认知更少,对贫困的内在归因更多,以及对再分配的支持更少。与此相符的是,想象自己经历了向上流动(与一开始就处于顶端并一直保持相比)会使人们认为这种流动不那么困难,从而减少对未能向上流动者的同情心和支持(研究3)。这些发现表明,变得富有可能会以与普遍直觉和文化假设相悖的方式改变对穷人的看法。