Beames Joanne R, Spanos Samantha, Roberts Anna, McGillivray Lauren, Li Sophie, Newby Jill M, O'Dea Bridianne, Werner-Seidler Aliza
Black Dog Institute, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW Australia.
Black Dog Institute and School of Psychology, University of New South Wales, Sydney, NSW Australia.
Educ Psychol Rev. 2023;35(1):26. doi: 10.1007/s10648-023-09720-w. Epub 2023 Mar 1.
This paper outlines a systematic review and meta-analyses to identify, describe, and evaluate randomised and non-randomised controlled trials of psychological programs targeting the mental health, professional burnout, and/or wellbeing of school classroom teachers. Eighty-eight unique studies were identified for inclusion in the review, and of those 46 were included in the meta-analyses (23 randomised controlled trials). In randomised controlled trials, the programs examined had large effects on stress (=0.93), and moderate effects on anxiety (=0.65), depression (=0.51), professional burnout (0.57), and wellbeing (=0.56) at post. In non-randomised controlled trials, programs had moderate effects on stress (0.50), and small effects on anxiety (=0.38) and wellbeing (=0.38) at post. Studies were heterogeneous in design and methodological quality was generally poor, particularly in non-randomised controlled trials. There was an inadequate number of comparisons to perform sub-group analyses, meta-regression, or publication bias analyses. Most of the programs examined required significant time, effort, and resources to deliver and complete. These programs may not translate well outside of research trials to real-world contexts due to teachers being time-poor. Priorities for research include using methodologically rigorous designs, developing programs for teachers with teachers (i.e. co-design), and considering implementation factors to ensure feasibility, acceptability, and uptake. Systematic Review Registration Number: PROPSERO - CRD42020159805.
The online version contains supplementary material available at 10.1007/s10648-023-09720-w.
本文概述了一项系统评价和荟萃分析,以识别、描述和评估针对学校课堂教师心理健康、职业倦怠和/或幸福感的心理项目的随机对照试验和非随机对照试验。共识别出88项独特研究纳入该评价,其中46项纳入荟萃分析(23项随机对照试验)。在随机对照试验中,所研究的项目在干预后对压力有较大影响(效应量=0.93),对焦虑(效应量=0.65)、抑郁(效应量=0.51)、职业倦怠(效应量=0.57)和幸福感(效应量=0.56)有中等影响。在非随机对照试验中,项目在干预后对压力有中等影响(效应量=0.50),对焦虑(效应量=0.38)和幸福感(效应量=0.38)有较小影响。研究在设计上存在异质性,方法学质量普遍较差,尤其是在非随机对照试验中。进行亚组分析、荟萃回归或发表偏倚分析的比较数量不足。大多数所研究的项目需要大量时间、精力和资源来实施和完成。由于教师时间紧张,这些项目在研究试验之外可能无法很好地转化为实际应用。研究重点包括采用方法学严谨的设计、与教师共同开发项目(即共同设计),并考虑实施因素以确保可行性、可接受性和采用率。系统评价注册号:PROSPERO - CRD42020159805。
在线版本包含可在10.1007/s10648 - 023 - 09720 - w获取的补充材料。