Department of Addictions, King's College London, London, United Kingdom.
Action on Smoking and Health (ASH), London, United Kingdom.
JAMA Netw Open. 2023 Mar 1;6(3):e231799. doi: 10.1001/jamanetworkopen.2023.1799.
e-Cigarette vaping among youths and adults has increased in Great Britain. The design of e-cigarette packaging may appeal to youths. Regulations that reduce the appeal of e-cigarettes to youths may deter adult smokers from trying e-cigarettes to help them quit smoking.
To examine the association of fully branded and standardized e-cigarette packaging with interest in trying products among youths and adults in Great Britain.
DESIGN, SETTING, AND PARTICIPANTS: In this survey study comprising 2 surveys, the online Action on Smoking and Health Smokefree Great Britain survey collected data between March 25 and April 16, 2021, from a representative sample of 2469 youths (aged 11-18 years) and between February 18 and March 18, 2021, from a representative sample of 12 046 adults (aged ≥18 years).
A between-individuals experimental design was used to examine participants' perceptions of e-cigarette packs that were digitally altered to remove brand imagery and color. Participants were randomly assigned to view a set of 3 e-cigarette packs from 1 of 3 different packaging conditions: (1) fully branded packs (control), (2) white standardized packs with brand name, or (3) green standardized packs with brand name.
Youth participants were asked which product people their age would be most interested in trying, while adult participants were asked which product they would be most interested in trying. All participants could respond "no interest" or "don't know." Logistic regression models tested whether reporting no interest in trying the e-cigarettes differed between the pack conditions.
This study included 2469 youths (1286 female youths [52.1%]; mean [SD] age, 15.0 [2.3] years) and 12 046 adults (6412 female [53.2%]; mean [SD] age, 49.9 [17.4] years). Youths had higher odds of reporting no interest among people their age in trying the e-cigarettes packaged in green (292 of 815 [35.8%]; adjusted odds ratio [AOR], 1.37; 95% CI, 1.10-1.71; P = .005) but not white (264 of 826 [32.0%]; AOR, 1.16; 95% CI, 0.93-1.44; P = .20) standardized packaging compared with the fully branded packaging (238 of 828 [28.7%]). Adults had lower odds of reporting no interest in trying e-cigarettes in green standardized packaging (3505 of 4040 [86.8%]; AOR, 0.85; 95% CI, 0.73-0.99; P = .046) but not white packaging (3532 of 4006 [88.2%]; AOR, 1.05; 95% CI, 0.89-1.23; P = .59) compared with branded packaging (3526 of 4000 [88.1%]). Youths who had never vaped (275 of 699 [39.3%]; AOR, 1.34; 95% CI, 1.07-1.69; P = .01) and youths who had never smoked (271 of 676 [40.1%]; AOR, 1.38; 95% CI, 1.10-1.75; P = .006) were more likely to report no interest in trying e-cigarettes in green packaging compared with branded packaging (224 of 688 [32.6%] never vaping; 216 of 662 [32.6%] never smoking). There were no significant differences by vaping or smoking status among adults.
The findings of this survey study suggest that standardized packaging measures may reduce the appeal of e-cigarettes among youths without reducing their appeal among adults.
在英国,青少年和成年人使用电子烟的情况有所增加。电子烟包装的设计可能会吸引青少年。减少电子烟对青少年吸引力的规定可能会阻止成年吸烟者尝试电子烟来帮助他们戒烟。
研究完全品牌化和标准化的电子烟包装与英国青少年和成年人尝试产品的兴趣之间的关联。
设计、环境和参与者:在这项包括两项调查的调查研究中,在线控烟行动协会的英国无烟调查于 2021 年 3 月 25 日至 4 月 16 日期间从代表性样本中收集了 2469 名青少年(年龄在 11-18 岁之间)的数据,于 2021 年 2 月 18 日至 3 月 18 日期间从代表性样本中收集了 12046 名成年人(年龄在 18 岁及以上)的数据。
采用个体间实验设计,研究参与者对电子烟包的看法,这些包装的数字图像和颜色被去除。参与者被随机分配观看来自 3 种不同包装条件的一组 3 个电子烟包:(1)完全品牌化包装(对照组)、(2)带有品牌名称的白色标准化包装、或(3)带有品牌名称的绿色标准化包装。
青少年参与者被问到他们这个年龄段的人最感兴趣尝试的产品是什么,而成年参与者被问到他们最感兴趣尝试的产品是什么。所有参与者都可以回答“不感兴趣”或“不知道”。逻辑回归模型测试了报告对电子烟没有兴趣尝试的情况是否在包装条件之间存在差异。
这项研究包括 2469 名青少年(1286 名女性青少年[52.1%];平均[SD]年龄,15.0[2.3]岁)和 12046 名成年人(6412 名女性[53.2%];平均[SD]年龄,49.9[17.4]岁)。青少年报告对他们这个年龄段的人对绿色包装的电子烟不感兴趣的可能性更高(815 人中有 292 人[35.8%];调整后的优势比[OR],1.37;95%置信区间[CI],1.10-1.71;P=0.005),但不是白色标准化包装(826 人中有 264 人[32.0%];OR,1.16;95%CI,0.93-1.44;P=0.20)与完全品牌化包装(828 人中有 238 人[28.7%])相比。成年人报告对绿色标准化包装的电子烟不感兴趣的可能性较低(4040 人中有 3505 人[86.8%];OR,0.85;95%CI,0.73-0.99;P=0.046),但不是白色标准化包装(4006 人中有 3532 人[88.2%];OR,1.05;95%CI,0.89-1.23;P=0.59)与品牌化包装(4000 人中有 3526 人[88.1%])相比。从未吸过电子烟的青少年(699 人中有 275 人[39.3%];OR,1.34;95%CI,1.07-1.69;P=0.01)和从未吸烟的青少年(676 人中有 271 人[40.1%];OR,1.38;95%CI,1.10-1.75;P=0.006)更有可能报告对绿色包装的电子烟不感兴趣,而不是品牌化包装(688 人中有 224 人[32.6%]从未吸过电子烟;662 人中有 216 人[32.6%]从未吸烟)。在成年人中,根据吸电子烟或吸烟的状况,没有发现显著差异。
这项调查研究的结果表明,标准化包装措施可能会降低电子烟对青少年的吸引力,而不会降低对成年人的吸引力。