Instituto de Ciencias e Innovación en Medicina (ICIM), Facultad de Medicina Clínica Alemana, Universidad del Desarrollo, Santiago, Chile.
Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York, UK.
BMC Infect Dis. 2023 Mar 14;23(1):158. doi: 10.1186/s12879-023-08118-x.
Globally, it has been reported that different social determinants of health -structural, sociodemographic, economic, living conditions and cultural factors- may affect opportunities to adhere to prevention measures against SARS-CoV-2. The objective of this study was to explore the perceptions around barriers and facilitators for adherence to COVID-19 prevention measures among the adult population residing in three large cities in Chile from a social determinants of health perspective.
Qualitative paradigm, multiple case-study design. Online semi-structured interviews were conducted with men and women aged 18 and over from different socioeconomic groups residing in three large cities. For participant recruitment and selection, purposive contacts were made based on community and social media networks, followed by snowball sampling. Saturation was reached at 61 participants, after which a thematic analysis was carried out with the support of AtlasTi software. The Ethics Committee of the Universidad del Desarrollo in Chile approved this study.
The main perceived barriers to adherence to COVID-19 preventive measures are linked to structural social determinants of health such as income, occupation, gender, access to basic supplies, and housing. Perceived facilitators are the fear of contagion and the incorporation of measures into daily habits. The social communication of preventive measures by health authorities is perceived as punitive, affecting adherence once the fear of contagion decreased in the country. It is also perceived that the recommended preventive measures are disconnected from communities' cultural practices and people´s identity, as well as affected by gender inequities and socioeconomic conditions that stakeholders in the country do not sufficiently address.
Study findings suggest that adherence to preventive measures, such as social distancing, mask use, and hand washing, could be promoted through their incorporation into the daily life habits of people and communities. These measures should consider the structural social determinants that generate multiple barriers to adherence, like poverty, occupational risks, and overcrowding. Socio-cultural dimensions of health and everyday risks need further understanding among the different communities in the country, allowing for differences in viewpoints and practices based on gender, age, place, and social identity.
全球范围内,已有研究报告指出,不同的健康社会决定因素——结构性、社会人口统计学、经济、生活条件和文化因素——可能会影响人们遵守针对 SARS-CoV-2 的预防措施的机会。本研究的目的是从健康的社会决定因素角度探讨智利三个大城市的成年居民对遵守 COVID-19 预防措施的障碍和促进因素的看法。
采用定性范式,多案例研究设计。对来自不同社会经济群体、年龄在 18 岁及以上的男性和女性进行了在线半结构化访谈。在参与者招募和选择方面,基于社区和社交媒体网络进行了有针对性的联系,然后进行了滚雪球抽样。在 61 名参与者达到饱和后,使用 AtlasTi 软件进行了主题分析。智利发展大学的伦理委员会批准了这项研究。
遵守 COVID-19 预防措施的主要感知障碍与收入、职业、性别、基本用品获取和住房等结构性社会决定因素有关。感知的促进因素是对感染的恐惧和将措施纳入日常习惯。卫生当局对预防措施的社会传播被认为是惩罚性的,一旦国家对感染的恐惧减少,就会影响遵守情况。人们还认为,建议的预防措施与社区的文化习俗和人们的身份脱节,并且受到性别不平等和社会经济条件的影响,而这些问题在该国并没有得到充分解决。
研究结果表明,可以通过将社会距离、戴口罩和洗手等预防措施纳入人们和社区的日常生活习惯来促进其遵守。这些措施应考虑到导致遵守障碍的结构性社会决定因素,例如贫困、职业风险和过度拥挤。健康的社会文化维度和日常风险需要在该国的不同社区中进一步理解,以允许基于性别、年龄、地点和社会身份的观点和实践的差异。