Sittiwang Supattra, Nimmapirat Pimjuta, Suttiwan Panrapee, Promduang Wathoosiri, Chaikittipornlert Nattapon, Wouldes Trecia, Prapamontol Tippawan, Naksen Warangkana, Promkam Nattawadee, Pingwong Sureewan, Breckheimer Adrian, Cadorett Valerie, Panuwet Parinya, Barr Dana Boyd, Baumert Brittney O, Ohman-Strickland Pamela, Fiedler Nancy
LIFE Di Center, Faculty of Psychology, Chulalongkorn University, Bangkok, Thailand.
Department of Psychological Medicine, The University of Auckland, Auckland, New Zealand.
Front Epidemiol. 2022;2. doi: 10.3389/fepid.2022.1039922. Epub 2022 Dec 14.
Organophosphate (OP) insecticides are among the most abundantly used insecticides worldwide. Thailand ranked third among 15 Asian countries in its use of pesticides per unit hectare and fourth in annual pesticide use. More than 40% of Thai women of childbearing age work on farms where pesticides are applied. Thus, the potential for pregnant women and their fetuses to be exposed to pesticides is significant. This study investigated the relationship between early, mid, and late pregnancy maternal urine concentrations of OP metabolites and infant neural integrity at 5 weeks of age.
We enrolled women employed on farms from two antenatal clinics in the Chiang Mai province of northern Thailand. We collected urine samples monthly during pregnancy, composited them by early, mid and late pregnancy and analyzed the composited samples for dialkylphosphate (DAP) metabolites of OP insecticides. At 5 weeks after birth, nurses certified in use of the NICU Network Neurobehavioral Scale (NNNS) completed the evaluation of 320 healthy infants. We employed generalized linear regression, logistic and Poisson models to determine the association between NNNS outcomes and DAP concentrations. All analyses were adjusted for confounders and included creatinine as an independent variable.
We did not observe trimester specific associations between DAP concentrations and NNNS outcomes. Instead, we observed statistically significant inverse associations between NNNS arousal (β = -0.10; CI: -0.17, -0.002; = 0.0091) and excitability [0.79 (0.68, 0.92; = 0.0026)] among participants with higher average prenatal DAP concentrations across pregnancy. We identified 3 NNNS profiles by latent profile analysis. Higher prenatal maternal DAP concentrations were associated with higher odds of being classified in a profile indicative of greater self-regulation and attention, but arousal and excitability scores below the 50th percentile relative to US normative samples [OR = 1.47 (CI: 1.05, 2.06; = 0.03)]. Similar findings are also observed among infants with prenatal exposure to substances of abuse (e.g., methamphetamine).
Overall, the associations between prenatal DAP concentrations and NNNS summary scores were not significant. Further evaluations are warranted to determine the implications of low arousal and excitability for neurodevelopmental outcomes of attention and memory and whether these results are transitory or imply inadequate responsivity to stimulation among children as they develop.
有机磷杀虫剂是全球使用最为广泛的杀虫剂之一。在每公顷农药使用量方面,泰国在15个亚洲国家中排名第三,在年度农药使用量方面排名第四。泰国超过40%的育龄妇女在使用农药的农场工作。因此,孕妇及其胎儿接触农药的可能性很大。本研究调查了妊娠早期、中期和晚期孕妇尿液中有机磷代谢物浓度与婴儿5周龄时神经完整性之间的关系。
我们招募了泰国北部清迈省两家产前诊所的农场女工。在孕期每月收集尿液样本,按妊娠早期、中期和晚期进行合并,并分析合并样本中有机磷杀虫剂的二烷基磷酸酯(DAP)代谢物。婴儿出生5周后,经新生儿重症监护病房网络神经行为量表(NNNS)认证的护士对320名健康婴儿进行了评估。我们采用广义线性回归、逻辑回归和泊松模型来确定NNNS结果与DAP浓度之间的关联。所有分析均对混杂因素进行了调整,并将肌酐作为自变量纳入。
我们未观察到DAP浓度与NNNS结果之间存在特定孕期的关联。相反,我们观察到,在整个孕期平均产前DAP浓度较高的参与者中,NNNS觉醒(β = -0.10;置信区间:-0.17,-0.002;P = 0.0091)和兴奋性[0.79(0.68,0.92;P = 0.0026)]之间存在统计学显著的负相关。我们通过潜在剖面分析确定了3种NNNS概况。产前母亲DAP浓度较高与被归类为表明更强自我调节和注意力的概况的较高几率相关,但相对于美国标准样本,觉醒和兴奋性得分低于第50百分位数[比值比 = 1.47(置信区间:1.05,2.06;P = 0.03)]。在产前接触滥用物质(如甲基苯丙胺)的婴儿中也观察到了类似的结果。
总体而言,产前DAP浓度与NNNS汇总评分之间的关联并不显著。有必要进行进一步评估,以确定低觉醒和兴奋性对注意力和记忆的神经发育结果的影响,以及这些结果是暂时的,还是意味着儿童在发育过程中对刺激的反应性不足。