Department of Radiology and Biomedical Imaging, University of California, San Francisco, San Francisco, CA, United States.
UC Berkeley-UCSF Graduate Program in Bioengineering, University of California, San Francisco, CA, United States.
Pain Med. 2023 Aug 4;24(Suppl 1):S149-S159. doi: 10.1093/pm/pnad035.
To evaluate whether combining fast acquisitions with deep-learning reconstruction can provide diagnostically useful images and quantitative assessment comparable to standard-of-care acquisitions for lumbar spine magnetic resonance imaging (MRI).
Eighteen patients were imaged with both standard protocol and fast protocol using reduced signal averages, each protocol including sagittal fat-suppressed T2-weighted, sagittal T1-weighted, and axial T2-weighted 2D fast spin-echo sequences. Fast-acquisition data was additionally reconstructed using vendor-supplied deep-learning reconstruction with three different noise reduction factors. For qualitative analysis, standard images as well as fast images with and without deep-learning reconstruction were graded by three radiologists on five different categories. For quantitative analysis, convolutional neural networks were applied to sagittal T1-weighted images to segment intervertebral discs and vertebral bodies, and disc heights and vertebral body volumes were derived.
Based on noninferiority testing on qualitative scores, fast images without deep-learning reconstruction were inferior to standard images for most categories. However, deep-learning reconstruction improved the average scores, and noninferiority was observed over 24 out of 45 comparisons (all with sagittal T2-weighted images while 4/5 comparisons with sagittal T1-weighted and axial T2-weighted images). Interobserver variability increased with 50 and 75% noise reduction factors. Deep-learning reconstructed fast images with 50% and 75% noise reduction factors had comparable disc heights and vertebral body volumes to standard images (r2≥ 0.86 for disc heights and r2≥ 0.98 for vertebral body volumes).
This study demonstrated that deep-learning-reconstructed fast-acquisition images have the potential to provide noninferior image quality and comparable quantitative assessment to standard clinical images.
评估快速采集结合深度学习重建是否可以提供具有诊断价值的图像和定量评估,与腰椎磁共振成像(MRI)的标准采集相比。
18 名患者分别使用减少的信号平均进行标准方案和快速方案成像,每个方案均包括矢状脂肪抑制 T2 加权、矢状 T1 加权和轴向 T2 加权 2D 快速自旋回波序列。快速采集数据还使用供应商提供的深度学习重建进行重建,具有三种不同的降噪因子。定性分析方面,三位放射科医生对标准图像以及带有和不带深度学习重建的快速图像进行了五个不同类别的评分。定量分析方面,应用卷积神经网络对矢状 T1 加权图像进行分割,以分割椎间盘和椎体,并得出椎间盘高度和椎体体积。
基于定性评分的非劣效性检验,大多数类别中,不带深度学习重建的快速图像劣于标准图像。然而,深度学习重建提高了平均评分,在 45 次比较中的 24 次观察到非劣效性(所有与矢状 T2 加权图像比较,而 4/5 次与矢状 T1 加权和轴向 T2 加权图像比较)。观察者间变异性随 50%和 75%的噪声降低因子增加而增加。具有 50%和 75%噪声降低因子的深度学习重建的快速图像与标准图像具有可比的椎间盘高度和椎体体积(椎间盘高度的 r2≥0.86,椎体体积的 r2≥0.98)。
本研究表明,深度学习重建的快速采集图像有可能提供不劣于标准临床图像的图像质量和定量评估。