Noreen Khola, Zuberi Rukhsana W, Aftab Kausar, Fatima Sabahat
Dr. Khola Noreen, Associate Professor, Community Medicine, Rawalpindi Medical University, Rawalpindi, Pakistan.
Prof. Dr. Rukhsana W Zuberi, Professor Emerita, Aga Khan University, Karachi, Pakistan.
Pak J Med Sci. 2023 Mar-Apr;39(2):330-337. doi: 10.12669/pjms.39.2.6608.
This study aims to develop and assess the content validity along with the reliability of a Professionalism Assessment Tool (PAT) with an intention to measure professionalism among undergraduate medical students.
This psychometric analytical study validation study was carried out at Rawalpindi Medical University from 1 February to 1 June, 2021 after establishing feasibility and obtaining ethical approval. The non-probability convince sampling was employed to collect data. Using Nunnally's, the ratio of e subjects per item was selected, as our preliminary tool has 48 items so 384 sample size was estimated for scale validation. The preliminary 48-item tool with five subscales(cSS) developed through mutual consensus by the Delphi technique namely Communication skill(cSS1),-7 item, Accountability(cSS2)-8 item, Altruism(cSS3)-13 item, Self-Directed Learning (cSS4)-10 item and Ethics(cSS5),-10 item was labelled as Professionalism Assessment Tool (PAT). The tool was administered to 4 year MBBS students, the data obtained was analyzed by calculating Cronbach's alpha to estimate the reliability. The SPSS version 26 was used for data analysis.
The 48-item PAT had an overall reliability (Cronbach's alpha) of 0.783. The Reliability of the new Subscales were communication skills (0.405), self-directed learning (0.527), Accountability (0.378), Altruism (0.486) and Ethics (0.715).
The final tool developed for assessment of professionalism had 48 items on a seven point Likert like scale, across five Subscales. Results showed that it was determined as a useful tool in assessing professionalism in undergraduate medical students to generate reliable results for valid decision-making.
本研究旨在开发并评估专业素养评估工具(PAT)的内容效度和信度,以测量本科医学生的专业素养。
本心理测量分析验证研究于2021年2月1日至6月1日在拉瓦尔品第医科大学进行,此前已确定可行性并获得伦理批准。采用非概率便利抽样收集数据。根据努纳利的方法,选择每个项目的受试者比例,由于我们的初步工具包含48个项目,因此估计量表验证的样本量为384。通过德尔菲技术经共同协商开发的包含五个子量表(cSS)的初步48项工具,即沟通技巧(cSS1)-7项、问责制(cSS2)-8项、利他主义(cSS3)-13项、自主学习(cSS4)-10项和伦理(cSS5)-10项,被标记为专业素养评估工具(PAT)。该工具应用于四年制医学学士学生,通过计算克朗巴哈系数分析所获数据以估计信度。使用SPSS 26版进行数据分析。
48项PAT的总体信度(克朗巴哈系数)为0.783。新子量表的信度分别为沟通技巧(0.405)、自主学习(0.527)、问责制(0.378)、利他主义(0.486)和伦理(0.715)。
为评估专业素养而开发的最终工具在七点李克特量表上有48个项目,涵盖五个子量表。结果表明,它被确定为评估本科医学生专业素养的有用工具,可为有效决策产生可靠结果。