Filip Pavel, Kokošová Viktória, Valenta Zdeněk, Baláž Marek, Mangia Silvia, Michaeli Shalom, Vojtíšek Lubomír
Department of Neurology, First Faculty of Medicine, Charles University and General University Hospital, Prague, Czechia.
Center for Magnetic Resonance Research (CMRR), University of Minnesota, Minneapolis, MN, United States.
Front Aging Neurosci. 2023 Mar 9;15:1099499. doi: 10.3389/fnagi.2023.1099499. eCollection 2023.
The advent of new, advanced quantitative MRI metrics allows for evaluation of multiple biological processes highly relevant for ageing. The presented study combines several MRI parameters hypothesised to detect distinct biological characteristics as myelin density, cellularity, cellular membrane integrity and iron concentration. 116 healthy volunteers, continuously distributed over the whole adult age span, underwent a multi-modal MRI protocol acquisition. Scatterplots of individual MRI metrics revealed that certain MRI protocols offer much higher sensitivity to early adulthood changes while plateauing in higher age (e.g., global functional connectivity in cerebral cortex or orientation dispersion index in white matter), while other MRI metrics provided reverse ability-stable levels in young adulthood with sharp changes with rising age (e.g., T1ρ and T2ρ). Nonetheless, despite the previously published validations of specificity towards microstructural biology based on cytoarchitectonic maps in healthy population or alterations in certain pathologies, several metrics previously hypothesised to be selective to common measures failed to show similar scatterplot distributions, pointing to further confounding factors directly related to age. Furthermore, other metrics, previously shown to detect different biological characteristics, exhibited substantial intercorrelations, be it due to the nature of the MRI protocol itself or co-dependence of relevant biological microstructural processes. All in all, the presented study provides a unique basis for the design and choice of relevant MRI parameters depending on the age group of interest. Furthermore, it calls for caution in simplistic biological inferences in ageing based on one simple MRI metric, even though previously validated under other conditions. Complex multi-modal approaches combining several metrics to extract the shared subcomponent will be necessary to achieve the desired goal of histological MRI.
新的先进定量MRI指标的出现使得评估与衰老高度相关的多个生物学过程成为可能。本研究结合了几个MRI参数,这些参数被假设用于检测不同的生物学特征,如髓磷脂密度、细胞密度、细胞膜完整性和铁浓度。116名健康志愿者,年龄连续分布在整个成年期,接受了多模态MRI检查。个体MRI指标的散点图显示,某些MRI检查对成年早期的变化具有更高的敏感性,而在较高年龄时趋于平稳(例如,大脑皮层的整体功能连接性或白质的方向分散指数),而其他MRI指标则具有相反的能力——在成年早期水平稳定,随着年龄增长急剧变化(例如,T1ρ和T2ρ)。尽管先前已发表了基于健康人群细胞结构图谱或某些病理学改变对微观结构生物学特异性的验证,但先前假设对常见测量具有选择性的几个指标未能显示出类似的散点图分布,这表明存在与年龄直接相关的进一步混杂因素。此外,其他先前显示能检测不同生物学特征的指标表现出显著的相互相关性,这可能是由于MRI检查本身的性质或相关生物学微观结构过程的相互依赖性。总而言之,本研究为根据感兴趣的年龄组设计和选择相关MRI参数提供了独特的基础。此外,它提醒人们在基于一个简单的MRI指标对衰老进行简单化生物学推断时要谨慎,即使该指标先前在其他条件下已得到验证。为了实现组织学MRI的预期目标,需要采用复杂的多模态方法,结合多个指标来提取共享的子成分。