Sawyer Erica, Laroche-Pinel Eve, Flasco Madison, Cooper Monica L, Corrales Benjamin, Fuchs Marc, Brillante Luca
Viticulture & Enology Research Center, California State University Fresno, Fresno, CA, United States.
Department of Mathematics, California State University Fresno, Fresno, CA, United States.
Front Plant Sci. 2023 Mar 10;14:1117869. doi: 10.3389/fpls.2023.1117869. eCollection 2023.
Grapevine leafroll-associated viruses (GLRaVs) and grapevine red blotch virus (GRBV) cause substantial economic losses and concern to North America's grape and wine industries. Fast and accurate identification of these two groups of viruses is key to informing disease management strategies and limiting their spread by insect vectors in the vineyard. Hyperspectral imaging offers new opportunities for virus disease scouting.
Here we used two machine learning methods, i.e., Random Forest (RF) and 3D-Convolutional Neural Network (CNN), to identify and distinguish leaves from red blotch-infected vines, leafroll-infected vines, and vines co-infected with both viruses using spatiospectral information in the visible domain (510-710nm). We captured hyperspectral images of about 500 leaves from 250 vines at two sampling times during the growing season (a pre-symptomatic stage at veraison and a symptomatic stage at mid-ripening). Concurrently, viral infections were determined in leaf petioles by polymerase chain reaction (PCR) based assays using virus-specific primers and by visual assessment of disease symptoms.
When binarily classifying infected vs. non-infected leaves, the CNN model reaches an overall maximum accuracy of 87% versus 82.8% for the RF model. Using the symptomatic dataset lowers the rate of false negatives. Based on a multiclass categorization of leaves, the CNN and RF models had a maximum accuracy of 77.7% and 76.9% (averaged across both healthy and infected leaf categories). Both CNN and RF outperformed visual assessment of symptoms by experts when using RGB segmented images. Interpretation of the RF data showed that the most important wavelengths were in the green, orange, and red subregions.
While differentiation between plants co-infected with GLRaVs and GRBV proved to be relatively challenging, both models showed promising accuracies across infection categories.
葡萄卷叶相关病毒(GLRaVs)和葡萄红斑点病毒(GRBV)给北美葡萄和葡萄酒产业造成了巨大经济损失并引发了关注。快速准确地识别这两类病毒是制定病害管理策略以及限制其在葡萄园通过昆虫媒介传播的关键。高光谱成像为病毒病害监测提供了新机遇。
在此,我们使用两种机器学习方法,即随机森林(RF)和三维卷积神经网络(3D-CNN),利用可见光谱域(510 - 710nm)的空间光谱信息,从感染红斑点病的葡萄藤、感染卷叶病的葡萄藤以及同时感染这两种病毒的葡萄藤中识别并区分叶片。在生长季节的两个采样时间(转色期的症状前期和果实成熟中期的症状期),我们采集了来自250株葡萄藤的约500片叶子的高光谱图像。同时,通过使用病毒特异性引物的聚合酶链反应(PCR)检测以及对病害症状的视觉评估,确定叶柄中的病毒感染情况。
在对感染叶片与未感染叶片进行二元分类时,CNN模型的总体最大准确率达到87%,而RF模型为82.8%。使用症状数据集可降低假阴性率。基于叶片的多类别分类,CNN和RF模型的最大准确率分别为77.7%和76.9%(在健康和感染叶片类别中平均)。当使用RGB分割图像时,CNN和RF在症状识别方面均优于专家的视觉评估。对RF数据的解读表明,最重要的波长位于绿色、橙色和红色子区域。
虽然区分同时感染GLRaVs和GRBV的植株相对具有挑战性,但两个模型在各类感染情况中都显示出了可观的准确率。