Department of Business, History and Social Sciences, University of South-Eastern Norway, Vestfold, Vestfold, Norway.
Department of Health Research, SINTEF Digital, Stiftelsen for Industriell Og Teknisk Forskning (SINTEF), Oslo, Oslo, Norway.
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023 Apr 1;23(1):328. doi: 10.1186/s12913-023-09325-7.
BACKGROUND: Low and lower middle-income countries suffer lack of healthcare providers and proper workforce education programs, a greater spread of illnesses, poor surveillance, efficient management, etc., which are addressable by a central policy framework implementation. Accordingly, an eHealth policy framework is required specifically for these countries to successfully implement eHealth solutions. This study explores existing frameworks and fills the gap by proposing an eHealth policy framework in the context of developing countries. METHODS: This PRISMA-based (PRISMA Preferred Reporting Items For Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) systematic review used Google Scholar, IEEE, Web of Science, and PubMed latest on 23 May 2022, explored 83 publications regarding eHealth policy frameworks, and extracted 11 publications scrutinizing eHealth policy frameworks in their title, abstract, or keywords. These publications were analyzed by using both expert opinion and Rstudio programming tools. They were explored based on their developing/developed countries' context, research approach, main contribution, constructs/dimensions of the framework, and related categories. In addition, by using cloudword and latent semantic space techniques, the most discussed concepts and targeted keywords were explored and a correlation test was conducted to depict the important concepts mentioned in the related literature and extract their relation with the targeted keywords in the interest of this study. RESULTS: Most of these publications do not develop or synthesize new frameworks for eHealth policy implementation, but rather introduce eHealth implementation frameworks, explain policy dimensions, identify and extract relevant components of existing frameworks or point out legal or other relevant eHealth implementation issues. CONCLUSION: After a thorough exploration of related literature, this study identified the main factors affecting an effective eHealth policy framework, found a gap in the context of developing countries, and proposed a four-step eHealth policy implementation guideline for successful implementation of eHealth in the context of developing. The limitation of this study is the lack of a proper amount of practically implemented eHealth policy framework cases in developing countries published in the literature for the review. Ultimately, this study is part of the BETTEReHEALTH (More information about the BETTEReHEALTH project at https://betterehealth.eu ) project funded by the European Union Horizon's 2020 under agreement number 101017450.
背景:低收入和中下收入国家缺乏医疗保健提供者和适当的劳动力教育计划,疾病传播范围更广,监测不力,管理效率低下等,这些问题可以通过实施中央政策框架来解决。因此,需要为这些国家制定具体的电子卫生政策框架,以成功实施电子卫生解决方案。本研究探讨了现有的框架,并通过在发展中国家的背景下提出电子卫生政策框架来填补这一空白。
方法:本研究基于 PRISMA(系统评价和荟萃分析的首选报告项目)进行了系统回顾,使用 Google Scholar、IEEE、Web of Science 和 PubMed 于 2022 年 5 月 23 日进行了最新搜索,共探讨了 83 篇关于电子卫生政策框架的出版物,并提取了 11 篇在标题、摘要或关键字中探讨电子卫生政策框架的出版物。使用专家意见和 Rstudio 编程工具对这些出版物进行了分析。它们是根据其发展/发达国家的背景、研究方法、主要贡献、框架的构建/维度以及相关类别进行探讨的。此外,通过使用 cloudword 和潜在语义空间技术,探讨了讨论最多的概念和目标关键字,并进行了相关测试,以描述相关文献中提到的重要概念,并提取它们与本研究中目标关键字的关系。
结果:这些出版物大多没有为电子卫生政策的实施制定或综合新的框架,而是介绍电子卫生实施框架,解释政策维度,确定和提取现有框架的相关组成部分,或指出法律或其他相关电子卫生实施问题。
结论:在对相关文献进行深入探讨后,本研究确定了影响电子卫生政策框架有效性的主要因素,发现了发展中国家背景下的差距,并提出了一个四步电子卫生政策实施指南,以在发展中国家成功实施电子卫生。本研究的局限性在于,文献中缺乏在发展中国家实际实施的电子卫生政策框架案例,无法进行审查。最终,本研究是由欧盟地平线 2020 资助的 BETTEReHEALTH(更多关于 BETTEReHEALTH 项目的信息请访问 https://betterehealth.eu)项目的一部分。
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023-4-1
Cochrane Database Syst Rev. 2022-2-1
BMC Health Serv Res. 2023-10-24
J Med Internet Res. 2023-8-17
J Med Internet Res. 2022-2-9
J Med Internet Res. 2025-6-9
Oxf Open Digit Health. 2024-12-2
BMC Health Serv Res. 2025-2-18
Aten Primaria. 2025-6
BMC Health Serv Res. 2020-6-23
Int J Technol Assess Health Care. 2020-6
Lancet Glob Health. 2018-11
J Med Internet Res. 2018-5-1
BMC Health Serv Res. 2014-1-3
J Med Internet Res. 2013-7-30
J Med Internet Res. 2011-12-5