Department of Radiology, Duke University Health System, 2301 Erwin Road, Box 3808, Durham, NC, 27110, USA.
Quantitative Imaging and Analysis Lab, Department of Radiology, Duke University, Durham, NC, USA.
Eur Radiol. 2023 Oct;33(10):7056-7065. doi: 10.1007/s00330-023-09644-7. Epub 2023 Apr 21.
Evaluate a novel algorithm for noise reduction in obese patients using dual-source dual-energy (DE) CT imaging.
Seventy-nine patients with contrast-enhanced abdominal imaging (54 women; age: 58 ± 14 years; BMI: 39 ± 5 kg/m, range: 35-62 kg/m) from seven DECT (SOMATOM Flash or Force) were retrospectively included (01/2019-12/2020). Image domain data were reconstructed with the standard clinical algorithm (ADMIRE/SAFIRE 2), and denoised with a comparison (ME-NLM) and a test algorithm (rank-sparse kernel regression). Contrast-to-noise ratio (CNR) was calculated. Four blinded readers evaluated the same original and denoised images (0 (worst)-100 (best)) in randomized order for perceived image noise, quality, and their comfort making a diagnosis from a table of 80 options. Comparisons between algorithms were performed using paired t-tests and mixed-effects linear modeling.
Average CNR was 5.0 ± 1.9 (original), 31.1 ± 10.3 (comparison; p < 0.001), and 8.9 ± 2.9 (test; p < 0.001). Readers were in good to moderate agreement over perceived image noise (ICC: 0.83), image quality (ICC: 0.71), and diagnostic comfort (ICC: 0.6). Diagnostic accuracy was low across algorithms (accuracy: 66, 63, and 67% (original, comparison, test)). The noise received a mean score of 54, 84, and 66 (p < 0.05); image quality 59, 61, and 65; and the diagnostic comfort 63, 68, and 68, respectively. Quality and comfort scores were not statistically significantly different between algorithms.
The test algorithm produces quantitatively higher image quality than current standard and existing denoising algorithms in obese patients imaged with DECT and readers show a preference for it.
Accurate diagnosis on CT imaging of obese patients is challenging and denoising algorithms can increase the diagnostic comfort and quantitative image quality. This could lead to better clinical reads.
• Improving image quality in DECT imaging of obese patients is important for accurate and confident clinical reads, which may be aided by novel denoising algorithms using image domain data. • Accurate diagnosis on CT imaging of obese patients is especially challenging and denoising algorithms can increase quantitative and qualitative image quality. • Image domain algorithms can generalize well and can be implemented at other institutions.
使用双源双能(DE)CT 成像评估一种用于肥胖患者降噪的新算法。
回顾性纳入 79 例接受腹部增强成像的患者(54 例女性;年龄:58±14 岁;BMI:39±5kg/m,范围:35-62kg/m),这些患者来自七台 DECT(SOMATOM Flash 或 Force)(01/2019-12/2020)。图像域数据使用标准临床算法(ADMIRE/SAFIRE 2)进行重建,并使用比较(ME-NLM)和测试算法(秩稀疏核回归)进行去噪。计算对比噪声比(CNR)。四名盲法读者以随机顺序评估相同的原始和去噪图像(0(最差)-100(最佳)),用于感知图像噪声、质量以及从 80 个选项表中诊断的舒适度。使用配对 t 检验和混合效应线性建模对算法进行比较。
平均 CNR 分别为 5.0±1.9(原始)、31.1±10.3(比较;p<0.001)和 8.9±2.9(测试;p<0.001)。读者在感知图像噪声(ICC:0.83)、图像质量(ICC:0.71)和诊断舒适度(ICC:0.6)方面具有良好到中度的一致性。在所有算法中,诊断准确性都较低(准确性:66%、63%和 67%(原始、比较、测试))。噪声的平均评分为 54、84 和 66(p<0.05);图像质量为 59、61 和 65;诊断舒适度为 63、68 和 68。算法之间的质量和舒适度评分没有统计学差异。
与 DECT 成像的肥胖患者目前的标准和现有的降噪算法相比,测试算法在定量上产生更高的图像质量,并且读者对其表现出偏好。
在肥胖患者的 CT 成像中准确诊断具有挑战性,降噪算法可以提高诊断舒适度和定量图像质量。这可能会带来更好的临床解读。
在肥胖患者的 DECT 成像中提高图像质量对于准确和有信心的临床解读很重要,这可能得益于使用图像域数据的新降噪算法。
在肥胖患者的 CT 成像中准确诊断尤其具有挑战性,降噪算法可以提高定量和定性图像质量。
图像域算法可以很好地推广,并可以在其他机构实施。