Mary MacKillop Institute for Health Research, Australian Catholic University, Melbourne, VIC,Australia.
Female Athlete Program, Boston Children's Hospital and Harvard Medical School, Boston, MA,USA.
Int J Sport Nutr Exerc Metab. 2023 May 9;33(4):198-208. doi: 10.1123/ijsnem.2022-0214. Print 2023 Jul 1.
The aim of this audit was to assess the representation of female athletes, dietary control methods, and gold standard female methodology that underpins the current guidelines for chronic carbohydrate (CHO) intake strategies for athlete daily training diets. Using a standardized audit, 281 studies were identified that examined high versus moderate CHO, periodized CHO availability, and/or low CHO, high fat diets. There were 3,735 total participants across these studies with only ∼16% of participants being women. Few studies utilized a design that specifically considered females, with only 16 studies (∼6%) including a female-only cohort and six studies (∼2%) with a sex-based comparison in their statistical procedure, in comparison to the 217 studies (∼77%) including a male-only cohort. Most studies (∼72%) did not provide sufficient information to define the menstrual status of participants, and of the 18 studies that did, optimal methodology for control of ovarian hormones was only noted in one study. While ∼40% of male-only studies provided all food and beverages to participants, only ∼20% of studies with a female-specific design used this approach for dietary control. Most studies did not implement strategies to ensure compliance to dietary interventions and/or control energy intake during dietary interventions. The literature that has contributed to the current guidelines for daily CHO intake is lacking in research that is specific to, or adequately addresses, the female athlete. Redressing this imbalance is of high priority to ensure that the female athlete receives evidence-based recommendations that consider her specific needs.
本次审核旨在评估女性运动员的代表性、饮食控制方法以及当前运动员日常训练饮食中慢性碳水化合物 (CHO) 摄入策略指南所依据的黄金标准女性方法学。使用标准化审核,确定了 281 项研究,这些研究检查了高 versus 中 CHO、周期性 CHO 供应以及低 CHO、高脂肪饮食。这些研究共涉及 3735 名参与者,其中只有约 16%的参与者是女性。很少有研究采用专门针对女性的设计,只有 16 项研究(约 6%)包括女性独有的队列,6 项研究(约 2%)在其统计过程中进行了基于性别的比较,而 217 项研究(约 77%)包括男性独有的队列。大多数研究(约 72%)没有提供足够的信息来定义参与者的月经状况,而在进行了这方面说明的 18 项研究中,只有一项研究注意到了控制卵巢激素的最佳方法学。虽然约 40%的仅包含男性的研究向参与者提供了所有食物和饮料,但只有约 20%的具有女性特定设计的研究采用了这种方法来进行饮食控制。大多数研究没有实施策略来确保对饮食干预的依从性,或在饮食干预期间控制能量摄入。为目前每日 CHO 摄入指南做出贡献的文献在针对女性运动员或充分解决女性运动员问题的研究方面存在不足。纠正这种不平衡具有高度优先性,以确保女性运动员获得考虑到其特殊需求的循证建议。