Massachusetts General Hospital, Boston, Massachusetts; and Northeastern University, Boston, Massachusetts.
Respir Care. 2023 Nov;68(11):1585-1597. doi: 10.4187/respcare.11170. Epub 2023 Jun 20.
Studies can be observational or experimental. With an observational study, the investigator does not determine the assignment of subjects, and there might not be a control group. If there is a control group, assignment of the independent variable (exposure or intervention) is not under the control of the investigator. Observational studies can be rigorously conducted, but the lack of random assignment of the exposure/intervention introduces confounding and bias. Thus, the quality of evidence resulting from observational studies is lower than that of experimental randomized controlled trials (RCTs). An observational study might be performed if an RCT is unethical, impractical, or outside the control of the investigator. There are many types of prospective and retrospective observational study designs. However, an observational study design should be avoided if an experimental study is possible. Sophisticated statistical approaches can be used, but this does not elevate an observational study to the level of an RCT. Regardless of quality, an observational study cannot establish causality.
研究可以是观察性的或实验性的。在观察性研究中,研究者不决定受试者的分配,也可能没有对照组。如果有对照组,那么独立变量(暴露或干预)的分配不受研究者的控制。观察性研究可以进行得很严格,但由于暴露/干预的随机分配缺失,会引入混杂和偏倚。因此,来自观察性研究的证据质量低于实验性随机对照试验(RCT)。如果 RCT 不道德、不切实际或超出研究者的控制,可能会进行观察性研究。有许多类型的前瞻性和回顾性观察性研究设计。然而,如果进行实验研究是可能的,就应该避免观察性研究设计。可以使用复杂的统计方法,但这并不能将观察性研究提升到 RCT 的水平。无论质量如何,观察性研究都不能确定因果关系。