Gower Menna, Morgan Frank, Saunders Julie
Faculty of Health and Medical Sciences, School of Population and Global Health, University of Western Australia, Perth, WA, Australia.
Psychiatr Psychol Law. 2022 Mar 14;30(3):249-270. doi: 10.1080/13218719.2021.2006098. eCollection 2023.
There is an over-representation of Aboriginal/Indigenous people in the criminal justice systems of Australia, Canada, New Zealand and the United States, with offences committed by male and female Aboriginal prisoners predominantly involving physical violence against a person. Risk assessment tools used have not been developed for Aboriginal people, and validations have produced varied results. The current study focused on violent offenders and investigated the differences between four demographic groups - Aboriginal females (AF), non-Aboriginal females (NAF), Aboriginal males (AM) and non-Aboriginal males (NAM) - on the Level of Service/Risk, Need, Responsivity (LS/RNR) and Violence Risk Scale (VRS; including Screening Version, VRS-SV). Significant differences were evident between all groups; however, there were limited differences between AF and NAF with differences on the VRS-SV primarily due to static factors. Aboriginality did not appear to elevate risk for violent females. The limitations of the study are discussed plus the recommendations for future research.
在澳大利亚、加拿大、新西兰和美国的刑事司法系统中,原住民/土著居民的比例过高,原住民男性和女性囚犯所犯罪行主要涉及对他人的身体暴力。所使用的风险评估工具并非针对原住民开发,验证结果也各不相同。当前的研究聚焦于暴力罪犯,调查了四个群体——原住民女性(AF)、非原住民女性(NAF)、原住民男性(AM)和非原住民男性(NAM)——在服务水平/风险、需求、响应性(LS/RNR)和暴力风险量表(VRS;包括筛查版,VRS-SV)方面的差异。所有群体之间都存在显著差异;然而,AF和NAF之间的差异有限,VRS-SV上的差异主要归因于静态因素。原住民身份似乎并未增加暴力女性的风险。本文讨论了该研究的局限性以及对未来研究的建议。