Gervasi Vincenzo, Sordilli Marco, Loi Federica, Guberti Vittorio
Istituto Superiore per la Protezione e la Ricerca Ambientale, Via Ca' Fornacetta, 9, 40064 Ozzano Emilia, Italy.
Direzione Generale Sanità Animale e Farmaci Veterinari, Ministero della Salute, Via Giorgio Ribotta, 5, 00144 Roma, Italy.
Pathogens. 2023 Jun 7;12(6):812. doi: 10.3390/pathogens12060812.
The early identification of the spreading patterns of an epidemic infectious disease is an important first step towards the adoption of effective interventions. We developed a simple regression-based method to estimate the directional speed of a disease's spread, which can be easily applied with a limited dataset. We tested the method using simulation tools, then applied it on a real case study of an African Swine Fever (ASF) outbreak identified in late 2021 in northwestern Italy. Simulations showed that, when carcass detection rates were <0.1, the model produced negatively biased estimates of the ASF-affected area, with the average bias being about -10%. When detection rates were >0.1, the model produced asymptotically unbiased and progressively more predictable estimates. The model produced rather different estimates of ASF's spreading speed in different directions of northern Italy, with the average speed ranging from 33 to 90 m/day. The resulting ASF-infected areas of the outbreak were estimated to be 2216 km, about 80% bigger than the ones identified only thorough field-collected carcasses. Additionally, we estimated that the actual initial date of the ASF outbreak was 145 days earlier than the day of first notification. We recommend the use of this or similar inferential tools as a quick, initial way to assess an epidemic's patterns in its early stages and inform quick and timely management actions.
早期识别流行性传染病的传播模式是采取有效干预措施的重要第一步。我们开发了一种基于简单回归的方法来估计疾病传播的方向速度,该方法可以在有限的数据集上轻松应用。我们使用模拟工具对该方法进行了测试,然后将其应用于2021年末在意大利西北部发现的非洲猪瘟(ASF)疫情的实际案例研究中。模拟结果表明,当尸体检测率<0.1时,该模型对受ASF影响区域的估计产生负偏差,平均偏差约为-10%。当检测率>0.1时,该模型产生渐近无偏且预测性逐渐增强的估计。该模型对意大利北部不同方向的ASF传播速度产生了相当不同的估计,平均速度范围为33至90米/天。此次疫情导致的ASF感染区域估计为2216平方公里,比仅通过实地收集尸体确定的区域大约80%。此外,我们估计ASF疫情的实际初始日期比首次通报日期早145天。我们建议使用这种或类似的推断工具作为一种快速的初始方法,以评估疫情早期阶段的模式,并为快速及时的管理行动提供信息。