Wynn Chelsea S, Fiks Alexander G, Localio Russell, Shults Justine, Nekrasova Ekaterina, Shone Laura P, Torres Alessandra, Griffith Miranda, Unger Rebecca, Ware Leigh Ann, Kelly Mary Kate, Stockwell Melissa S
Division of Child and Adolescent Health, Department of Pediatrics, Columbia University Vagelos College of Physicians and Surgeons, New York, NY, United States.
Department of Pediatrics, Clinical Futures & PolicyLab, Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, Philadelphia, PA, United States.
JMIR Form Res. 2023 Jun 30;7:e39576. doi: 10.2196/39576.
Mobile health (mHealth) is quickly expanding as a method of health promotion, but some interventions may not be familiar or comfortable for potential users. SMS text messaging has been investigated as a low-cost, accessible way to provide vaccine reminders. Most (97%) US adults own a cellphone and of those adults most use SMS text messaging. However, understanding patterns of SMS text message plan type and use in diverse primary care populations needs more investigation.
We sought to use a survey to examine baseline SMS text messaging and data plan patterns among families willing to accept SMS text message vaccine reminders.
As part of a National Institutes of Health (NIH)-funded national study (Flu2Text) conducted during the 2017-2018 and 2018-2019 influenza seasons, families of children needing a second seasonal influenza vaccine dose were recruited in pediatric primary care offices at the time of their first dose. Practices were from the American Academy of Pediatrics' (AAP) Pediatric Research in Office Settings (PROS) research network, the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia, and Columbia University. A survey was administered via telephone (Season 1) or electronically (Season 2) at enrollment. Standardized (adjusted) proportions for SMS text message plan type and texting frequency were calculated using logistic regression that was adjusted for child and caregiver demographics.
Responses were collected from 1439 participants (69% of enrolled). The mean caregiver age was 32 (SD 6) years, and most children (n=1355, 94.2%) were aged 6-23 months. Most (n=1357, 94.3%) families were English-speaking. Most (n=1331, 92.8%) but not all participants had an unlimited SMS text messaging plan and sent or received texts at least once daily (n=1313, 91.5%). SMS text messaging plan type and use at baseline was uniform across most but not all subgroups. However, there were some differences in the study population's SMS text messaging plan type and usage. Caregivers who wanted Spanish SMS text messages were less likely than those who chose English to have an unlimited SMS text messaging plan (n=61, 86.7% vs n=1270, 94%; risk difference -7.2%, 95% CI -27.1 to -1.8). There were no significant differences in having an unlimited plan associated with child's race, ethnicity, age, health status, insurance type, or caregiver education level. SMS text messaging use at baseline was not uniform across all subgroups. Nearly three-quarters (n=1030, 71.9%) of participants had received some form of SMS text message from their doctor's office; most common were appointment reminders (n=1014, 98.4%), prescription (n=300, 29.1%), and laboratory notifications (n=117, 11.4%). Even the majority (n=64, 61.5%) of those who did not have unlimited plans and who texted less than daily (n=72, 59%) reported receipt of these SMS text messages.
In this study, most participants had access to unlimited SMS text messaging plans and texted at least once daily. However, infrequent texting and lack of access to an unlimited SMS text messaging plan did not preclude enrolling to receive SMS text message reminders in pediatric primary care settings.
移动健康(mHealth)作为一种健康促进方法正在迅速发展,但某些干预措施可能不为潜在用户所熟悉或接受。短信已被视作一种提供疫苗提醒的低成本且便捷的方式。大多数(97%)美国成年人拥有手机,且这些成年人大多使用短信。然而,对于不同基层医疗人群的短信套餐类型及使用模式仍需深入研究。
我们试图通过一项调查来研究愿意接受短信疫苗提醒的家庭的短信及数据套餐基线模式。
作为美国国立卫生研究院(NIH)资助的一项全国性研究(Flu2Text)的一部分,该研究在2017 - 2018年和2018 - 2019年流感季开展,需要接种第二剂季节性流感疫苗的儿童家庭在其首次接种时于儿科基层医疗诊所被招募。参与机构来自美国儿科学会(AAP)的门诊儿科研究(PROS)网络、费城儿童医院和哥伦比亚大学。在入组时通过电话(第一季)或电子方式(第二季)进行调查。使用逻辑回归计算短信套餐类型和短信发送频率的标准化(调整后)比例,并根据儿童及照料者的人口统计学特征进行调整。
共收集到1439名参与者的回复(占入组人数的69%)。照料者的平均年龄为32(标准差6)岁,大多数儿童(n = 1355,94.2%)年龄在6 - 23个月。大多数(n = 1357,94.3%)家庭说英语。大多数(n = 1331,92.8%)但并非所有参与者拥有无限制短信套餐且每天至少收发一次短信(n = 1313,91.5%)。在大多数但并非所有亚组中,短信套餐类型及基线使用情况较为一致。然而,研究人群的短信套餐类型及使用情况存在一些差异。希望接收西班牙语短信的照料者相比选择英语的照料者拥有无限制短信套餐的可能性更低(n = 61,86.7% 对 n = 1270,94%;风险差异 -7.2%,95%置信区间 -27.1至 -1.8)。在拥有无限制套餐方面,与儿童的种族、民族、年龄、健康状况、保险类型或照料者教育水平无关,不存在显著差异。短信使用的基线情况在所有亚组中并不一致。近四分之三(n = 1030,71.9%)的参与者收到过来自其医生办公室的某种形式的短信;最常见的是预约提醒(n = 1014,98.4%)、处方(n = 300,29.1%)和实验室通知(n = 117,11.4%)。即使是大多数(n = 64,61.5%)没有无限制套餐且短信发送频率低于每日一次的人(n = 72,59%)也报告收到过这些短信。
在本研究中,大多数参与者能够使用无限制短信套餐且每天至少发送一次短信。然而,短信发送频率低以及无法使用无限制短信套餐并不妨碍在儿科基层医疗环境中登记接收短信提醒。