Ma Junji, Chen Xitian, Gu Yue, Li Liangfang, Lin Ying, Dai Zhengjia
Department of Psychology, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
Guangdong Provincial Key Laboratory of Brain Function and Disease, Zhongshan School of Medicine, Sun Yat-sen University, Guangzhou, China.
Netw Neurosci. 2023 Jun 30;7(2):604-631. doi: 10.1162/netn_a_00291. eCollection 2023.
The human brain structural network is thought to be shaped by the optimal trade-off between cost and efficiency. However, most studies on this problem have focused on only the trade-off between cost and global efficiency (i.e., integration) and have overlooked the efficiency of segregated processing (i.e., segregation), which is essential for specialized information processing. Direct evidence on how trade-offs among cost, integration, and segregation shape the human brain network remains lacking. Here, adopting local efficiency and modularity as segregation factors, we used a multiobjective evolutionary algorithm to investigate this problem. We defined three trade-off models, which represented trade-offs between cost and integration (Dual-factor model), and trade-offs among cost, integration, and segregation (local efficiency or modularity; Tri-factor model), respectively. Among these, synthetic networks with optimal trade-off among cost, integration, and modularity (Tri-factor model []) showed the best performance. They had a high recovery rate of structural connections and optimal performance in most network features, especially in segregated processing capacity and network robustness. Morphospace of this trade-off model could further capture the variation of individual behavioral/demographic characteristics in a domain-specific manner. Overall, our results highlight the importance of modularity in the formation of the human brain structural network and provide new insights into the original cost-efficiency trade-off hypothesis.
人类大脑结构网络被认为是由成本与效率之间的最优权衡塑造而成的。然而,关于这个问题的大多数研究仅关注成本与全局效率(即整合)之间的权衡,而忽略了分离处理(即隔离)的效率,而分离处理对于专门的信息处理至关重要。关于成本、整合和隔离之间的权衡如何塑造人类大脑网络的直接证据仍然缺乏。在这里,我们采用局部效率和模块化作为隔离因素,使用多目标进化算法来研究这个问题。我们定义了三种权衡模型,分别代表成本与整合之间的权衡(双因素模型),以及成本、整合和隔离(局部效率或模块化;三因素模型)之间的权衡。其中,在成本、整合和模块化之间具有最优权衡的合成网络(三因素模型[])表现出最佳性能。它们具有较高的结构连接恢复率,并且在大多数网络特征方面具有最优性能,特别是在分离处理能力和网络鲁棒性方面。这种权衡模型的形态空间可以进一步以特定领域的方式捕捉个体行为/人口统计学特征的变化。总体而言,我们的结果突出了模块化在人类大脑结构网络形成中的重要性,并为原始的成本-效率权衡假设提供了新的见解。