Gdańsk University of Physical Education and Sport, Gdańsk, Poland.
Escola Superior Desporto e Lazer, Instituto Politécnico de Viana do Castelo, Viana do Castelo, Portugal.
Sci Prog. 2023 Jul-Sep;106(3):368504231187501. doi: 10.1177/00368504231187501.
This study aimed to compare the agreement of total distance (TD), high-speed running (HSR) distance, and sprint distance during 16 official soccer matches between a global navigation satellite system (GNSS) and an optical-tracking system. A total of 24 male soccer players, who are actively participating in the Polish Ekstraklasa professional league, were included in the analysis conducted during official competitions. The players were systematically monitored using Catapult GNSS (10-Hz, S7) and Tracab optical-tracking system (25-Hz, ChyronHego). TD, HSR distance, sprint distance, HSR count (HSRC), and sprint count (SC) were collected. The data were extracted in 5-min epochs. A statistical approach was employed to visually examine the relationship between the systems based on the same measure. Additionally, was utilized as a metric to quantify the proportion of variance accounted for by a variable. To assess agreement, Bland-Altman plots were visually inspected. The data from both systems were compared using the estimates derived from the intraclass correlation (ICC) test and Pearson product-moment correlation. Finally, a paired -test was employed to compare the measurements obtained from both systems. The interaction between Catapult and Tracab systems revealed an of 0.717 for TD, 0.512 for HSR distance, 0.647 for sprint distance, 0.349 for HSRC, and 0.261 for SC. The ICC values for absolute agreement between the systems were excellent for TD (ICC = 0.974) and good for HSR distance (ICC = 0.766), sprint distance (ICC = 0.822). The ICC values were not good for HSRCs (ICC = 0.659) and SCs (ICC = 0.640). -test revealed significant differences between Catapult and Tracab for TD ( < 0.001; = -0.084), HSR distance ( < 0.001; = -0.481), sprint distance ( < 0.001; = -0.513), HSRC ( < 0.001; = -0.558), and SC ( < 0.001; = -0.334). Although both systems present acceptable agreement in TD, they may not be perfectly interchangeable, which sports scientists and coaches must consider when using them.
本研究旨在比较全球导航卫星系统(GNSS)和光学跟踪系统在 16 场正式足球比赛中测量的总距离(TD)、高速跑动(HSR)距离和冲刺距离的一致性。共有 24 名活跃在波兰 Ekstraklasa 职业联赛的男性足球运动员参与了这项分析。在正式比赛中,运动员被系统地使用 Catapult GNSS(10Hz,S7)和 Tracab 光学跟踪系统(25Hz,ChyronHego)进行监测。收集了 TD、HSR 距离、冲刺距离、HSR 计数(HSRC)和冲刺计数(SC)。数据以 5 分钟的时间段提取。使用相同的测量值,采用统计方法来直观地检查系统之间的关系。此外, 被用作量化变量解释的方差比例的度量。为了评估一致性,通过 Bland-Altman 图进行了直观检查。使用来自组内相关(ICC)测试和 Pearson 积矩相关的估计值对两个系统的数据进行了比较。最后,使用配对 t 检验比较了两个系统的测量值。Catapult 和 Tracab 系统之间的相互作用显示 TD 为 0.717,HSR 距离为 0.512,冲刺距离为 0.647,HSRC 为 0.349,SC 为 0.261。系统之间绝对一致性的 ICC 值对于 TD(ICC=0.974)和 HSR 距离(ICC=0.766)、冲刺距离(ICC=0.822)都非常好。HSRCs(ICC=0.659)和 SCs(ICC=0.640)的 ICC 值不太好。t 检验显示 Catapult 和 Tracab 之间在 TD( <0.001; = -0.084)、HSR 距离( <0.001; = -0.481)、冲刺距离( <0.001; = -0.513)、HSRC( <0.001; = -0.558)和 SC( <0.001; = -0.334)方面存在显著差异。尽管这两个系统在 TD 方面具有可接受的一致性,但它们可能不完全可互换,体育科学家和教练在使用它们时必须考虑到这一点。