Kashyap Amrit, Plis Sergey, Ritter Petra, Keilholz Shella
Berlin Institute of Health at Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Department of Neurology with Experimental Neurology, Brain Simulation Section, Charité - Universitätsmedizin Berlin, corporate member of Freie Universitat Berlin and Humboldt-Universitat zu Berlin, Berlin, Germany.
Front Neurosci. 2023 Jul 17;17:1159914. doi: 10.3389/fnins.2023.1159914. eCollection 2023.
Brain Network Models (BNMs) are mathematical models that simulate the activity of the entire brain. These models use neural mass models to represent local activity in different brain regions that interact with each other via a global structural network. Researchers have been interested in using these models to explain measured brain activity, particularly resting state functional magnetic resonance imaging (rs-fMRI). BNMs have shown to produce similar properties as measured data computed over longer periods of time such as average functional connectivity (FC), but it is unclear how well simulated trajectories compare to empirical trajectories on a timepoint-by-timepoint basis. During task fMRI, the relevant processes pertaining to task occur over the time frame of the hemodynamic response function, and thus it is important to understand how BNMs capture these dynamics over these short periods.
To test the nature of BNMs' short-term trajectories, we used a deep learning technique called Neural ODE to simulate short trajectories from estimated initial conditions based on observed fMRI measurements. To compare to previous methods, we solved for the parameterization of a specific BNM, the Firing Rate Model, using these short-term trajectories as a metric.
Our results show an agreement between parameterization of using previous long-term metrics with the novel short term metrics exists if also considering other factors such as the sensitivity in accuracy with relative to changes in structural connectivity, and the presence of noise.
Therefore, we conclude that there is evidence that by using Neural ODE, BNMs can be simulated in a meaningful way when comparing against measured data trajectories, although future studies are necessary to establish how BNM activity relate to behavioral variables or to faster neural processes during this time period.
脑网络模型(BNMs)是模拟整个大脑活动的数学模型。这些模型使用神经团块模型来表示不同脑区的局部活动,这些脑区通过一个全局结构网络相互作用。研究人员一直对使用这些模型来解释测量到的大脑活动感兴趣,特别是静息态功能磁共振成像(rs-fMRI)。BNMs已被证明能产生与长时间计算得到的测量数据相似的特性,如平均功能连接性(FC),但尚不清楚模拟轨迹与逐时间点的经验轨迹相比的效果如何。在任务功能磁共振成像期间,与任务相关的过程发生在血液动力学响应函数的时间框架内,因此了解BNMs如何在这些短时间内捕捉这些动态变化很重要。
为了测试BNMs短期轨迹的性质,我们使用了一种名为神经常微分方程(Neural ODE)的深度学习技术,根据观察到的功能磁共振成像测量结果从估计的初始条件模拟短期轨迹。为了与之前的方法进行比较,我们使用这些短期轨迹作为指标来求解特定BNM(即 firing rate模型)的参数化。
我们的结果表明,如果还考虑其他因素,如相对于结构连接性变化的准确性敏感性和噪声的存在,那么使用先前长期指标的参数化与新的短期指标之间存在一致性。
因此,我们得出结论,有证据表明通过使用神经常微分方程,在与测量数据轨迹进行比较时,BNMs可以以有意义的方式进行模拟,尽管未来的研究有必要确定在此期间BNM活动如何与行为变量或更快的神经过程相关。