Department of Music, Durham University, Durham, UK.
Department of Psychology, Goldsmiths, University of London, London, UK.
Memory. 2023 Nov;31(10):1259-1268. doi: 10.1080/09658211.2023.2256055. Epub 2023 Sep 7.
Previous studies have found that music evokes more vivid and emotional memories of autobiographical events than various other retrieval cues. However, it is possible such findings can be explained by pre-existing differences between disparate events that are retrieved in response to each cue type. To test whether music exhibits differential effects to other cues even when memory encoding is controlled, we compared music and environmental sounds as cues for memories of the same set of dynamic visual scenes. Following incidental encoding of 14 scenes (7 with music, 7 with sounds), the music and sounds were presented to participants (= 56), who were asked to describe the scenes associated with these cues, and rate various memory properties. Music elicited fewer correct memories and more effortful retrieval than sound cues, and no difference was found in memory detail/vividness between cue types. However, music-evoked memories were rated as more positive and less arousing. These findings provide important critical insights that only partially support the common notion that music differs from other cue types in its effects on episodic memory retrieval.
先前的研究发现,与各种其他检索线索相比,音乐能唤起对自传事件更生动、更情绪化的记忆。然而,这些发现也可能是由于每种线索类型所检索到的不同事件之间预先存在的差异所导致的。为了测试即使在控制记忆编码的情况下音乐是否会表现出与其他线索不同的效果,我们比较了音乐和环境声音作为同一组动态视觉场景记忆的线索。在对 14 个场景进行偶然编码(7 个有音乐,7 个有声音)后,向参与者(= 56 人)呈现音乐和声音,要求他们描述与这些线索相关的场景,并对各种记忆属性进行评分。与声音线索相比,音乐线索引出的正确记忆较少,检索更费力,而线索类型之间的记忆细节/生动性没有差异。然而,音乐唤起的记忆被评为更积极、不那么令人兴奋。这些发现提供了重要的批判性见解,仅部分支持了音乐在其对情景记忆检索的影响方面与其他线索类型不同的普遍观点。