Moss Rachael H, Kelly Brian, Bird Philippa K, Pickett Kate E
Bradford Institute for Health Research, Bradford Teaching Hospitals Foundation Trust, Bradford, UK.
Leeds Teaching Hospitals NHS Trust, Leeds, UK.
SSM Popul Health. 2023 Jul 3;23:101463. doi: 10.1016/j.ssmph.2023.101463. eCollection 2023 Sep.
Subjective social status is how a person perceives their social class relative to other people and has frequently been associated with people's health and well-being. A frequently used measure of subjective social status is the MacArthur Scale of Subjective Social Status that depicts social status as a 10 rung ladder, asking individuals to rank themselves on this ladder relative to other people, either in their local neighbourhood or wider society. The Born in Bradford's Better Start birth cohort study aims to understand the lives, relationships, wellbeing, and social and economic circumstances of pregnant women and their children in three inner city areas of Bradford, UK. Pregnant mothers were asked to report their subjective social status, using the MacArthur subjective social status scales, comparing themselves to other people in their local neighbourhood and in England as a whole. This paper explores the characteristics of the women who gave responses, examines associations between the MacArthur subjective social status measures and other subjective and objective measures and looks specifically at the characteristics of women who reported either very low or very high subjective social status. On average, women reported that they had a higher social status compared to others within their local neighbourhood ( ladder rung = 6) and, although participants were from areas of Bradford with very high levels of deprivation, 23% placed themselves on the top three rungs, 8-10. Respondents reported that they had an average social status when comparing themselves to people in all of England ( ladder rung = 5) and 13% placed themselves on the top rungs 8-10. These findings raise important questions about the interpretation of the MacArthur scale of subjective social status.
主观社会地位是指一个人相对于其他人如何看待自己的社会阶层,并且经常与人们的健康和幸福联系在一起。一个常用的主观社会地位衡量标准是麦克阿瑟主观社会地位量表,该量表将社会地位描绘为一个有10级的阶梯,要求个人相对于其他人,无论是在当地社区还是更广泛的社会中,在这个阶梯上对自己进行排名。英国布拉德福德的“更好的开始”出生队列研究旨在了解英国布拉德福德三个内城区孕妇及其子女的生活、人际关系、幸福状况以及社会和经济状况。孕妇被要求使用麦克阿瑟主观社会地位量表报告她们的主观社会地位,将自己与当地社区以及整个英国的其他人进行比较。本文探讨了做出回应的女性的特征,研究了麦克阿瑟主观社会地位衡量标准与其他主观和客观衡量标准之间的关联,并特别关注报告主观社会地位非常低或非常高的女性的特征。平均而言,女性报告说,与当地社区的其他人相比,她们的社会地位更高(阶梯等级为6),而且尽管参与者来自布拉德福德贫困程度非常高的地区,但23%的人将自己排在最高的三级,即8 - 10级。受访者报告说,与全英国的人相比,他们的社会地位处于中等水平(阶梯等级为5),13%的人将自己排在最高的8 - 10级。这些发现引发了关于麦克阿瑟主观社会地位量表解释的重要问题。