Department of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, Queen Mary Hospital, Hong Kong, China (Hong Kong).
Department of Obstetrics & Gynaecology, The University of Hong Kong, Hong Kong, China (Hong Kong).
J Med Internet Res. 2023 Sep 19;25:e46663. doi: 10.2196/46663.
Integrating telehealth in an obstetric care model is important to prepare for possible infection outbreaks that require social distancing and limit in-person consultations. To ensure the successful implementation of obstetric telehealth in Hong Kong, it is essential to understand and address pregnant women's concerns.
This study aimed to assess pregnant women's attitudes, concerns, and perceptions regarding telehealth obstetric clinic services in Hong Kong.
We conducted a prospective cross-sectional questionnaire study at Queen Mary Hospital between November 2021 and August 2022. Utilizing a 5-point rating scale, the questionnaire aimed to capture pregnant women's preferences, expectations, feasibility perceptions, and privacy concerns related to telehealth clinic services. We used statistical analyses, including chi-square tests and multinomial logistic regression, to compare questionnaire responses and investigate the association between advancing gestation and attitudes toward telehealth clinics.
The study included 664 participants distributed across different pregnancy stages: 269 (40.5%) before 18 gestational weeks, 198 (29.8%) between 24 and 31 weeks, and 197 (29.7%) after delivery. Among them, 49.8% (329/664) favored face-to-face consultations over telehealth clinics, and only 7.3% (48/664) believed the opposite. Additionally, 24.2% (161/664) agreed that telehealth clinics should be launched for obstetric services. However, the overall preference for telehealth clinics was <20% for routine prenatal checkups (81/664, 12.2%) and addressing pregnancy-related concerns, such as vaginal bleeding (76/664, 11.5%), vaginal discharge (128/664, 19.4%), reduced fetal movement (64/664, 9.7%), uterine contractions (62/664, 9.4%), and suspected leakage of amniotic fluid (54/664, 8.2%). Conversely, 76.4% (507/664) preferred telehealth clinics to in-person visits for prenatal education talks, prenatal and postpartum exercise, and addressing breastfeeding problems. Participants were more comfortable with telehealth clinic tasks for tasks like explaining pregnancy exam results (418/664, 63.1%), self-administering urinary dipsticks at home (373/664, 56.4%), medical history-taking (341/664, 51.5%), and self-monitoring blood pressure using an electronic machine (282/664, 42.8%). %). During the postpartum period, compared to before 18 weeks of gestation, significantly more participants agreed that telehealth clinics could be an option for assessing physical symptoms such as vaginal bleeding (aOR 2.105, 95% CI 1.448-3.059), reduced fetal movement (aOR 1.575, 95% CI 1.058-2.345), uterine contractions (aOR 2.906, 95% CI 1.945-4.342), suspected leakage of amniotic fluid (aOR 2.609, 95% CI 1.721-3.954), fever (aOR 1.526, 95% CI 1.109-2.100), and flu-like symptoms (aOR 1.412, 95% CI 1.030-1.936). They were also more confident with measuring the symphysis-fundal height, arranging further investigations, and making diagnoses with the doctor via the telehealth clinic. The main perceived public health advantage of telehealth clinics was the shorter traveling and waiting time (526/664, 79.2%), while the main concern was legal issues from wrong diagnosis and treatment (511/664, 77.4%).
Face-to-face consultation remained the preferred mode of consultation among the participants. However, telehealth clinics could be an alternative for services that do not require physical examination or contact. An increased acceptance of and confidence in telehealth was found with advancing gestation and after delivery. Enforcing stricter laws and guidelines could facilitate the implementation of telehealth clinics and increase confidence in their use among pregnant women for obstetric care.
将远程医疗纳入产科护理模式对于应对可能需要社会隔离和限制面对面咨询的传染病爆发非常重要。为了确保在香港成功实施产科远程医疗,了解并解决孕妇的担忧至关重要。
本研究旨在评估香港孕妇对远程医疗产科诊所服务的态度、关注和看法。
我们于 2021 年 11 月至 2022 年 8 月在玛丽医院进行了一项前瞻性横断面问卷调查研究。该问卷采用 5 分制评分,旨在了解孕妇对远程医疗诊所服务的偏好、期望、可行性认知以及与远程医疗诊所服务相关的隐私问题。我们使用了统计分析,包括卡方检验和多项逻辑回归,比较了问卷回答并调查了孕周与对远程医疗诊所的态度之间的关联。
研究纳入了 664 名不同孕期的参与者,分布如下:18 孕周前 269 名(40.5%),24-31 孕周 198 名(29.8%),产后 197 名(29.7%)。其中,49.8%(329/664)更喜欢面对面咨询,而只有 7.3%(48/664)认为相反。此外,24.2%(161/664)认为应该推出远程医疗服务。然而,对于常规产前检查(81/664,12.2%)和处理与妊娠相关的问题,如阴道出血(76/664,11.5%)、阴道分泌物(128/664,19.4%)、胎儿运动减少(64/664,9.7%)、子宫收缩(62/664,9.4%)和疑似羊水渗漏(54/664,8.2%),孕妇对远程医疗诊所的整体偏好低于 20%。相反,76.4%(507/664)更喜欢远程医疗诊所进行产前教育讲座、产前和产后锻炼以及解决母乳喂养问题。对于产前检查结果的解释(418/664,63.1%)、在家进行尿试纸自检(373/664,56.4%)、病史采集(341/664,51.5%)和使用电子血压计自我监测血压(282/664,42.8%)等远程医疗诊所任务,参与者感到更加舒适。在产后期间,与 18 孕周前相比,更多的参与者认为远程医疗诊所可以用于评估阴道出血(调整后的优势比 [aOR] 2.105,95%置信区间 [CI] 1.448-3.059)、胎儿运动减少(aOR 1.575,95% CI 1.058-2.345)、子宫收缩(aOR 2.906,95% CI 1.945-4.342)、疑似羊水渗漏(aOR 2.609,95% CI 1.721-3.954)、发热(aOR 1.526,95% CI 1.109-2.100)和流感样症状(aOR 1.412,95% CI 1.030-1.936)等身体症状的选择。他们对通过远程医疗诊所测量耻骨联合-宫底高度、安排进一步检查和与医生做出诊断也更有信心。远程医疗诊所的主要公共卫生优势是缩短了就诊和等待时间(526/664,79.2%),而主要的关注问题是误诊和漏诊带来的法律问题(511/664,77.4%)。
面对面咨询仍然是参与者首选的咨询模式。然而,对于不需要体检或接触的服务,远程医疗诊所可以作为替代选择。随着孕周的增加和分娩后,对远程医疗的接受程度和信心有所增加。加强法律法规可以促进远程医疗诊所的实施,并增加孕妇对产科保健远程医疗的使用信心。