Avella Pasquale, Cappuccio Micaela, Cappuccio Teresa, Rotondo Marco, Fumarulo Daniela, Guerra Germano, Sciaudone Guido, Santone Antonella, Cammilleri Francesco, Bianco Paolo, Brunese Maria Chiara
HPB Surgery Unit, Pineta Grande Hospital, Castel Volturno, 81030 Caserta, Italy.
Department of Clinical Medicine and Surgery, University of Naples "Federico II", 80131 Naples, Italy.
Life (Basel). 2023 Oct 9;13(10):2027. doi: 10.3390/life13102027.
Artificial Intelligence (AI)-based analysis represents an evolving medical field. In the last few decades, several studies have reported the diagnostic efficiency of AI applied to Computed Tomography (CT) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) to early detect liver metastases (LM), mainly from colorectal cancer. Despite the increase in information and the development of different procedures in several radiological fields, an accurate method of predicting LM has not yet been found. This review aims to compare the diagnostic efficiency of different AI methods in the literature according to accuracy, sensibility, precision, and recall to identify early LM.
A narrative review of the literature was conducted on PubMed. A total of 336 studies were screened.
We selected 17 studies from 2012 to 2022. In total, 14,475 patients were included, and more than 95% were affected by colorectal cancer. The most frequently used imaging tool to early detect LM was found to be CT (58%), while MRI was used in three cases. Four different AI analyses were used: deep learning, radiomics, machine learning, and fuzzy systems in seven (41.18%), five (29.41%), four (23.53%), and one (5.88%) cases, respectively. Four studies achieved an accuracy of more than 90% after MRI and CT scan acquisition, while just two reported a recall rate ≥90% (one method using MRI and CT and one CT).
Routinely acquired radiological images could be used for AI-based analysis to early detect LM. Simultaneous use of radiomics and machine learning analysis applied to MRI or CT images should be an effective method considering the better results achieved in the clinical scenario.
基于人工智能(AI)的分析代表了一个不断发展的医学领域。在过去几十年中,多项研究报告了将AI应用于计算机断层扫描(CT)和磁共振成像(MRI)以早期检测肝转移瘤(LM)的诊断效率,主要是针对结直肠癌。尽管在多个放射学领域信息有所增加且不同程序不断发展,但尚未找到一种准确预测LM的方法。本综述旨在根据准确性、敏感性、精确性和召回率比较文献中不同AI方法的诊断效率,以识别早期LM。
对PubMed上的文献进行叙述性综述。共筛选了336项研究。
我们选择了2012年至2022年的17项研究。总共纳入了14475例患者,其中超过95%为结直肠癌患者。发现早期检测LM最常用的成像工具是CT(58%),而MRI仅在3例中使用。使用了四种不同的AI分析方法:深度学习、放射组学、机器学习和模糊系统,分别用于7例(41.18%)、5例(29.41%)、4例(23.53%)和1例(5.88%)。四项研究在进行MRI和CT扫描后准确率超过90%,而只有两项报告召回率≥90%(一种方法使用MRI和CT,一种使用CT)。
常规获取的放射学图像可用于基于AI的分析以早期检测LM。考虑到在临床场景中取得的较好结果,将放射组学和机器学习分析同时应用于MRI或CT图像应是一种有效的方法。