Neuroradiology Unit, Azienda Unità Sanitaria Locale-IRCCS di Reggio Emilia, Reggio Emilia, Italy.
Department of Neurology, University Hospital and University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Eur Stroke J. 2023 Dec;8(4):842-879. doi: 10.1177/23969873231190431. Epub 2023 Oct 30.
The European Stroke Organisation (ESO) guideline on Primary Angiitis of the Central Nervous System (PACNS), developed according to ESO standard operating procedures (SOP) and Grading of Recommendations, Assessment, Development and Evaluation (GRADE) methodology, was elaborated to assist clinicians in the diagnostic and treatment pathway of patients with PACNS in their decision making. A working group involving vascular neurologists, neuroradiologists, rheumatologists, a neuropathologist and a methodologist identified 17 relevant clinical questions; these were addressed according to the patient/population, intervention, comparison and outcomes (PICO) framework and systematic literature reviews were performed. Notably, each PICO was addressed with respect to large vessel (LV)-PACNS and small vessel (SV)-PACNS. Data to answer many questions were scarce or lacking and the quality of evidence was very low overall, so, for some PICOs, the recommendations reflect the ongoing uncertainty. When the absence of sufficient evidence precluded recommendations, Expert Consensus Statements were formulated. In some cases, this applied to interventions in the diagnosis and treatment of PACNS which are embedded widely in clinical practice, for example patterns of cerebrospinal fluid (CSF) and Magnetic Resonance Imaging (MRI) abnormalities. CSF analysis for hyperproteinorrachia and pleocytosis does not have evidence supporting their use as diagnostic tools. The working group recommended that caution is employed in the interpretation of non-invasive vascular imaging due to lack of validation and the different sensitivities in comparison with digital subtraction angiography (DSA) and histopathological analyses. Moreover, there is not a neuroimaging pattern specific for PACNS and neurovascular issues are largely underreported in PACNS patients. The group's recommendations on induction and maintenance of treatment and for primary or secondary prevention of vascular events also reflect uncertainty due to lack of evidence. Being uncertain the role and practical usefulness of current diagnostic criteria and being not comparable the main treatment strategies, it is suggested to have a multidisciplinary team approach in an expert center during both work up and management of patients with suspected PACNS. Highlighting the limitations of the currently accepted diagnostic criteria, we hope to facilitate the design of multicenter, prospective clinical studies and trials. A standardization of neuroimaging techniques and reporting to improve the level of evidence underpinning interventions employed in the diagnosis and management of PACNS. We anticipate that this guideline, the first comprehensive European guideline on PACNS management using GRADE methodology, will assist clinicians to choose the most effective management strategy for PACNS.
欧洲卒中组织 (ESO) 发布的原发性中枢神经系统血管炎 (PACNS) 指南,是根据 ESO 标准操作程序 (SOP) 和推荐分级评估、制定与评价 (GRADE) 方法学制定的,旨在协助临床医生为 PACNS 患者制定诊断和治疗方案。一个由血管神经病学家、神经放射学家、风湿病学家、神经病理学家和方法学家组成的工作组确定了 17 个相关的临床问题;根据患者/人群、干预、比较和结局 (PICO) 框架进行了处理,并进行了系统的文献回顾。值得注意的是,每个 PICO 都针对大血管 (LV)-PACNS 和小血管 (SV)-PACNS 进行了处理。回答许多问题的数据很少或缺乏,总体证据质量非常低,因此,对于一些 PICO,建议反映了持续存在的不确定性。当缺乏足够的证据时,制定了专家共识声明。在某些情况下,这适用于广泛嵌入临床实践中的 PACNS 诊断和治疗干预措施,例如脑脊液 (CSF) 和磁共振成像 (MRI) 异常模式。CSF 分析高蛋白血症和细胞增多症没有证据支持将其作为诊断工具使用。工作组建议在解释非侵入性血管成像时要谨慎,因为缺乏验证,并且与数字减影血管造影 (DSA) 和组织病理学分析相比,其敏感性不同。此外,没有特定于 PACNS 的神经影像学模式,并且 PACNS 患者的神经血管问题报告很少。该工作组关于诱导和维持治疗以及一级或二级预防血管事件的建议也反映了由于缺乏证据而存在的不确定性。由于不确定当前诊断标准的作用和实际有用性,并且主要治疗策略不可比较,因此建议在怀疑患有 PACNS 的患者的检查和管理过程中,在专家中心采用多学科团队方法。强调目前接受的诊断标准的局限性,我们希望促进多中心、前瞻性临床试验的设计。标准化神经影像学技术和报告,以提高诊断和管理 PACNS 中使用的干预措施的证据水平。我们预计,该指南是使用 GRADE 方法学制定的首个关于 PACNS 管理的全面欧洲指南,将有助于临床医生为 PACNS 选择最有效的管理策略。