Hoppe Hanno, Hirschle Dominique, Schumacher Martin Christian, Schönhofen Heinz, Glenck Michael, Kalka Christoph, Willenberg Torsten, Sixt Sebastian, Müller Dominik, Gutzeit Andreas, Christe Andreas, Mohan Vignes, Diehm Nicolas
University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
Department of Health Sciences and Medicine, University of Lucerne, Lucerne, Switzerland.
CVIR Endovasc. 2023 Nov 17;6(1):56. doi: 10.1186/s42155-023-00403-9.
Venous leak appears to be the most common cause of vasculogenic erectile dysfunction (ED), which can be treated with venous embolization. Traditionally, conventional cavernosography was used for the diagnosis and treatment planning of venous leak. Recently, computed tomography (CT) cavernosography was introduced as a novel cross-sectional imaging method proposed to be advantageous over conventional cavernosography. We created a novel management algorithm for diagnosing venous leak including CT cavernosography as an imaging modality. In order to provide a broader basis for our management algorithm, a systematic literature review was conducted.
In this article we systematically review relevant literature on using CT cavernosography for the diagnosis and treatment planning in ED patients with venous leak following the PRISMA selection process. Nine full-text articles were included in the review and assigned a level of evidence grade (all grade II). Two studies (2/9) compared the results of conventional cavernosography with those of CT cavernosography which was superior for site-specific venous leak identification (19.4% vs. 100%, respectively). CT cavernosography is a more detailed imaging method that is faster to perform, exposes the patient to less radiation, and requires less contrast material. In one study (1/9), CT cavernosography was used for diagnostic purposes only. Eight studies (8/9) cover both, diagnostic imaging and treatment planning including embolization (1/9) and sclerotherapy (2/9) of venous leak in patients with venogenic ED. Three studies (3/9) describe anatomical venous leak classifications that were established based on CT cavernosography findings for accurate mapping of superficial and/or deep venous leak and identification of mixed or more complex forms of venous leak present in up to 84% of patients. In addition to treatment planning, one study (1/9) used CT cavernosography also for follow-up imaging post treatment.
CT cavernosography is superior to conventional cavernosography for diagnosis and treatment planning in patients with ED caused by venous leak (grade II levels of evidence). Consequently, CT cavernosography should be included in management algorithms for ED patients with suspected venous leak.
静脉漏似乎是血管性勃起功能障碍(ED)最常见的病因,可通过静脉栓塞治疗。传统上,常规海绵体造影用于静脉漏的诊断和治疗规划。最近,计算机断层扫描(CT)海绵体造影作为一种新型的横断面成像方法被引入,被认为比常规海绵体造影更具优势。我们创建了一种用于诊断静脉漏的新型管理算法,将CT海绵体造影作为一种成像方式。为了为我们的管理算法提供更广泛的基础,我们进行了一项系统的文献综述。
在本文中,我们按照PRISMA筛选流程系统地回顾了有关使用CT海绵体造影对静脉漏型ED患者进行诊断和治疗规划的相关文献。该综述纳入了9篇全文文章,并赋予证据等级(均为II级)。两项研究(2/9)比较了常规海绵体造影与CT海绵体造影的结果,CT海绵体造影在特定部位静脉漏识别方面更具优势(分别为19.4%和100%)。CT海绵体造影是一种更详细的成像方法,操作更快,使患者接受的辐射更少,且所需造影剂更少。在一项研究(1/9)中,CT海绵体造影仅用于诊断目的。八项研究(8/9)涵盖了诊断成像和治疗规划,包括静脉性ED患者静脉漏的栓塞治疗(1/9)和硬化治疗(2/9)。三项研究(3/9)描述了基于CT海绵体造影结果建立的解剖学静脉漏分类,用于准确绘制浅表和/或深部静脉漏,并识别高达84%患者中存在的混合性或更复杂形式的静脉漏。除治疗规划外,一项研究(1/9)还将CT海绵体造影用于治疗后的随访成像。
对于静脉漏导致的ED患者,CT海绵体造影在诊断和治疗规划方面优于常规海绵体造影(证据等级为II级)。因此,对于疑似静脉漏的ED患者,管理算法应纳入CT海绵体造影。