Center for Indonesia's Strategic Development Initiatives (CISDI), Jakarta, Indonesia.
PLoS One. 2023 Dec 29;18(12):e0293913. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0293913. eCollection 2023.
The global trend of diets high in sugar sweetened beverages (SSB) is associated with a high risk of obesity and non-communicable diseases (NCDs). To reduce SSB consumption on a population level, SSB taxes have become a popular policy solution. In Indonesia, although the prevalence of obesity has doubled in the past decade (11.7% in 2010 to 21.8% in 2018), SSB taxes have not yet been implemented. Utilizing the 2021 Indonesian household socioeconomic survey (SUSENAS), this study estimated price elasticities and projected the plausible effects of implementing an SSB tax on consumers' demand for SSBs and the associated government revenue using the Quadratic Almost Ideal Demand System (QUAIDS) model. Five SSB groups were studied: 1) manufactured liquid milk; 2) sweetened condense milk; 3) instant coffee; 4) tea drinks and fizzy drinks with CO2; 5) fruit juices, "health" drinks, and energy drinks. The overall results showed that the non-milk SSB groups were price elastic. Probing deeper into the substitutions for SSB across categories, we found both substitutionary and complementary effects. Our analysis revealed that increasing SSB prices by 20% would reduce the demand for SSBs on average by 17.5% (14.3%-18.6% for each SSB group) and generate additional state revenue up to IDR 3,628.3 billion per year (approximately US$ 238.5 million or 0.2% of total tax revenue in 2022). Considering the health and economic impacts of high consumption of SSBs, this study provides empirical evidence that imposing taxes on SSBs could be an effective measure to reduce public consumption and to generate tax revenue for financing health programs that address obesity and NCDs in Indonesia.
全球高糖甜味饮料(SSB)饮食趋势与肥胖和非传染性疾病(NCD)的高风险相关。为了在人群层面减少 SSB 的消费,SSB 税已成为一种流行的政策解决方案。在印度尼西亚,尽管肥胖率在过去十年中翻了一番(2010 年为 11.7%,2018 年为 21.8%),但 SSB 税尚未实施。本研究利用 2021 年印度尼西亚家庭社会经济调查(SUSENAS),使用二次近似理想需求系统(QUAIDS)模型估计价格弹性,并预测对 SSB 征税对消费者对 SSB 的需求以及相关政府收入的可能影响。研究了五类 SSB 组:1)加工液态奶;2)加糖炼乳;3)速溶咖啡;4)含二氧化碳的茶饮料和碳酸饮料;5)果汁、“健康”饮料和能量饮料。总体结果表明,非牛奶 SSB 组的价格具有弹性。深入探究 SSB 之间的替代关系,我们发现了替代和互补效应。我们的分析表明,将 SSB 价格提高 20%,平均将减少 17.5%的 SSB 需求(每个 SSB 组 14.3%-18.6%),并产生高达 36283 亿印尼盾(约 2.385 亿美元或 2022 年总税收的 0.2%)的额外国家收入。考虑到高 SSB 消费对健康和经济的影响,本研究提供了实证证据,表明对 SSB 征税可能是减少公共消费和为解决印度尼西亚肥胖和 NCD 问题的健康计划提供资金的有效措施。