Department of Sociology and Interuniversity Center for Social Science Theory and Methodology, University of Groningen, Groningen, the Netherlands.
J Youth Adolesc. 2024 Mar;53(3):550-562. doi: 10.1007/s10964-023-01937-w. Epub 2024 Jan 6.
Positive and negative leadership styles may influence classroom norms and be related to the school and psychological adjustment of children in general, and victims in particular. This study tested the relation between leadership styles and children's adjustment, and the moderating effects of leadership on the association between self-reported victimization and school and psychological adjustment (self-esteem, social anxiety, and depressive symptoms); and it tested for potential gender differences. Classrooms were classified into those with only positive leaders, only negative leaders, both positive and negative leaders, and without leaders. The sample contained 8748 children (M = 10.05, SD = 1.22; 51.2% girls) from 392 classrooms, in grades three to six, in 98 Dutch schools. Multilevel analysis revealed that, in general, children in negative leader classrooms experienced lower school well-being than children in other classrooms. In positive leader classrooms, male and female victims had lower school well-being. For psychological well-being, female victims had lower self-esteem and more depressive symptoms in positive leader classrooms. Male and female victims in negative leader classrooms did not suffer from additional maladjustment. These results demonstrate that negative leadership styles are related to lower school well-being of all children, whereas victimization in classrooms with positive leaders is negatively related to male and female victims' school well-being and girls' psychological adjustment (depressive symptoms); this is in line with the 'healthy context paradox'.
积极和消极的领导风格可能会影响课堂规范,并与儿童的学校和心理适应有关,尤其是受害者。本研究检验了领导风格与儿童适应之间的关系,以及领导对自我报告的受害与学校和心理适应(自尊、社交焦虑和抑郁症状)之间关联的调节作用;并检验了潜在的性别差异。将课堂分为只有积极领导的、只有消极领导的、既有积极领导又有消极领导的和没有领导的。样本包括来自 98 所荷兰学校的 392 个班级的 8748 名儿童(M=10.05,SD=1.22;51.2%为女生),他们在三到六年级。多层次分析表明,一般来说,消极领导课堂上的儿童比其他课堂上的儿童的学校幸福感较低。在积极领导的课堂上,男性和女性受害者的学校幸福感较低。对于心理健康,在积极领导的课堂上,女性受害者的自尊心较低,抑郁症状较多。在消极领导的课堂上,男性和女性受害者没有遭受更多的适应不良。这些结果表明,消极的领导风格与所有儿童的较低学校幸福感有关,而在积极领导的课堂上,受害与男女生的学校幸福感以及女生的心理适应(抑郁症状)呈负相关;这符合“健康环境悖论”。