Zadro Joshua R, Ferreira Giovanni E, Stahl-Timmins Will, Egger Veronika, Elkins Mark R, Gamble Andrew R, O'Keeffe Mary, McCaffery Kirsten J, Harris Ian A, Ardern Clare L, West Courtney A, Maher Chris G, Hoffmann Tammy C
Sydney Musculoskeletal Health, Institute for Musculoskeletal Health, Sydney School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health, The University of Sydney and Sydney Local Health District, Sydney, NSW, Australia
Sydney Musculoskeletal Health, Institute for Musculoskeletal Health, Sydney School of Public Health, Faculty of Medicine and Health, The University of Sydney and Sydney Local Health District, Sydney, NSW, Australia.
BMJ Evid Based Med. 2024 Jan 19;29(5):342-345. doi: 10.1136/bmjebm-2023-112784.
People often use infographics (also called visual or graphical abstracts) as a substitute for reading the full text of an article. This is a concern because most infographics do not present sufficient information to interpret the research appropriately and guide wise health decisions. The Reporting Infographics and Visual Abstracts of Comparative studies (RIVA-C) checklist and guide aims to improve the completeness with which research findings of comparative studies are communicated and avoid research findings being misinterpreted if readers do not refer to the full text. The primary audience for the RIVA-C checklist and guide is developers of infographics that summarise comparative studies of health and medical interventions. The need for the RIVA-C checklist and guide was identified by a survey of how people use infographics. Possible checklist items were informed by a systematic review of how infographics report research. We then conducted a two-round, modified Delphi survey of 92 infographic developers/designers, researchers, health professionals and other key stakeholders. The final checklist includes 10 items. Accompanying explanation and both text and graphical examples linked to the items were developed and pilot tested over a 6-month period. The RIVA-C checklist and guide was designed to facilitate the creation of clear, transparent and sufficiently detailed infographics which summarise comparative studies of health and medical interventions. Accurate infographics can ensure research findings are communicated appropriately and not misinterpreted. By capturing the perspectives of a wide range of end users (eg, authors, informatics editors, journal editors, consumers), we are hopeful of rapid endorsement and implementation of RIVA-C.
人们常常使用信息图表(也称为视觉或图形摘要)来替代阅读文章全文。这令人担忧,因为大多数信息图表并未提供足够信息来恰当地解读研究并指导明智的健康决策。比较研究的信息图表报告与视觉摘要(RIVA-C)清单及指南旨在提高比较研究结果传达的完整性,并避免读者不参考全文时研究结果被误解。RIVA-C清单及指南的主要受众是总结健康与医学干预比较研究的信息图表开发者。RIVA-C清单及指南的需求是通过一项关于人们如何使用信息图表的调查确定的。可能的清单项目是通过对信息图表如何报告研究的系统综述得出的。然后,我们对92名信息图表开发者/设计师、研究人员、健康专业人员及其他关键利益相关者进行了两轮改进的德尔菲调查。最终清单包含10项内容。相关解释以及与这些项目相关的文本和图形示例在6个月的时间里进行了开发和试点测试。RIVA-C清单及指南旨在促进创建清晰、透明且足够详细的信息图表,以总结健康与医学干预的比较研究。准确的信息图表能够确保研究结果得到恰当传达且不被误解。通过收集广泛的终端用户(如作者、信息学编辑、期刊编辑、消费者)的观点,我们希望RIVA-C能迅速得到认可和实施。