Hatori Tsuyoshi, Bhandary Netra Prakash
Department of Environmental Design, Ehime University, Matsuyama, Japan.
Front Psychol. 2024 Feb 1;15:1295807. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2024.1295807. eCollection 2024.
Public response to restriction policy against the novel coronavirus disease (COVID-19) can polarize into two extremes: one absolutely in favor of restrictions for the sake of human life and health, and other absolutely against the restrictions for the sake of human rights and daily life. This study examines psychological nature of extremism regarding individuals' self-restraint from social behavior, which was and has been encouraged by the Japanese government as restriction measures, as well as possible measures to mitigate this extremism. We hypothesize that people with more extreme views on self-restraint tend to have less knowledge of this virus, and, nevertheless, tend to be more overconfident in the sense that they falsely believe they understand COVID-19 and the effects of self-restraint. It is also postulated that overconfidence can be reduced by asking them to explain how self-restraint works. To test these hypotheses, we conducted an online experiment on the Japanese adults ( = 500) to measure the extent of their knowledge of COVID-19 and to examine the effect of explanation task on their understanding regarding COVID-19 and extremism. The results indicate that the extreme attitudes were associated with insufficient knowledge about the symptoms, risks, and characteristics of COVID-19. Moreover, their extreme attitudes tended to moderate through this experimental study to an extent that they realized they did not understand COVID-19 including the effects of self-restraint. This suggests that people with extremism may have been overconfident in their own understanding of the COVID-19 restrictions.
公众对新型冠状病毒病(COVID-19)限制政策的反应可能两极分化为两个极端:一个极端是绝对支持为了人类生命和健康而实施的限制措施,另一个极端是绝对反对为了人权和日常生活而实施的限制措施。本研究考察了个人在社会行为中自我约束方面极端主义的心理本质,这种自我约束是日本政府作为限制措施一直鼓励的,同时也探讨了缓解这种极端主义的可能措施。我们假设,对自我约束持更极端观点的人往往对这种病毒了解较少,然而,他们往往过度自信,错误地认为自己了解COVID-19以及自我约束的影响。还假设通过要求他们解释自我约束是如何起作用的,可以降低过度自信。为了检验这些假设,我们对500名日本成年人进行了一项在线实验,以测量他们对COVID-19的了解程度,并考察解释任务对他们对COVID-19的理解以及极端主义的影响。结果表明,极端态度与对COVID-19的症状、风险和特征的了解不足有关。此外,通过这项实验研究,他们的极端态度在一定程度上趋于缓和,因为他们意识到自己并不了解COVID-19,包括自我约束的影响。这表明,持极端主义观点的人可能对自己对COVID-19限制措施的理解过于自信。