Department of Health Sciences, University of York, York, Fulford, UK.
Tees Esk and Wear Valleys NHS Foundation Trust, Darlington, West Park, UK.
Health Expect. 2024 Apr;27(2):e13997. doi: 10.1111/hex.13997.
Problem-solving skills (PSS) help to provide a systematic approach to dealing with and managing complex problems. The overall aim of this study was to assess the acceptability and feasibility of developing and adapting a prison-based PSS workbook for adults within a medium- and low-secure hospital.
We used the Medical Research Council framework in our participatory mixed methods study incorporating an adapted survey (to identify what types of problems people experience in secure hospitals), a series of three interactive workshops (to co-produce two case study examples for a workbook) and we gathered feedback from patients and hospital staff on the acceptability and feasibility of the workbook. Data from the survey were used to inform the case study examples, and the feedback from patients and hospital staff was descriptively summarised and the results consolidated.
In total, 82 (51%) patients took part in the survey; 22 patients and 49 hospital staff provided feedback on the workbook. The survey results indicated that patients regularly experience problems while in the hospital. Patients reported problems relating to restrictions of freedom and boredom. The workshops produced two case studies for the workbooks, with mainly positive patient and staff feedback. More work is required to improve the visual representation of the characters in the case studies, the amount and content of the language and the mechanism of the intervention delivery.
The adaptation process proved acceptable and feasible to both patients and staff. The co-production methodology for the workbook and feedback from patients and staff was an effective way of iteratively refining the materials to ensure that they were both meaningful and acceptable to staff and patients. Subsequent work is required to develop the workbook and evaluate the feasibility of the intervention delivery, recruitment rates, uptake and adherence to the PSS using a randomised controlled trial.
At each stage of the project consultation with patients and/or hospital staff was involved.
解决问题的能力(PSS)有助于提供一种系统的方法来处理和管理复杂问题。本研究的总体目标是评估在中低安全医院为成年人开发和改编基于监狱的 PSS 工作手册的可接受性和可行性。
我们在我们的参与式混合方法研究中使用了医学研究委员会框架,该研究结合了一项改编后的调查(以确定人们在安全医院中遇到的问题类型)、一系列三个互动研讨会(为工作手册共同制作两个案例研究示例),并收集了患者和医院工作人员对工作手册的可接受性和可行性的反馈。调查数据用于为案例研究示例提供信息,患者和医院工作人员的反馈以描述性方式进行总结并整合结果。
共有 82 名(51%)患者参加了调查;22 名患者和 49 名医院工作人员对工作簿提供了反馈。调查结果表明,患者在住院期间经常遇到问题。患者报告了与限制自由和无聊相关的问题。研讨会为工作手册制作了两个案例研究,主要得到了患者和工作人员的积极反馈。需要进一步改进案例研究中角色的视觉表现、语言的数量和内容以及干预措施的实施机制。
改编过程对患者和工作人员来说都是可接受和可行的。工作手册的共同制作方法和患者和工作人员的反馈是一种有效的方法,可以反复改进材料,确保其对工作人员和患者都有意义和可接受。需要进一步开展工作来开发工作手册,并使用随机对照试验评估干预措施实施、招募率、接受率和对 PSS 的依从性的可行性。
在项目的每个阶段都涉及与患者和/或医院工作人员的咨询。