Department of Health Financing, World Health Organization, 20 Avenue Appia, 1211Geneva, Switzerland.
Bull World Health Organ. 2024 Mar 1;102(3):216-224. doi: 10.2471/BLT.23.290333. Epub 2023 Dec 8.
There is increasing use of machine learning for the health financing functions (revenue raising, pooling and purchasing), yet evidence lacks for its effects on the universal health coverage (UHC) objectives. This paper provides a synopsis of the use cases of machine learning and their potential benefits and risks. The assessment reveals that the various use cases of machine learning for health financing have the potential to affect all the UHC intermediate objectives - the equitable distribution of resources (both positively and negatively); efficiency (primarily positively); and transparency (both positively and negatively). There are also both positive and negative effects on all three UHC final goals, that is, utilization of health services in line with need, financial protection and quality care. When the use of machine learning facilitates or simplifies health financing tasks that are counterproductive to UHC objectives, there are various risks - for instance risk selection, cost reductions at the expense of quality care, reduced financial protection or over-surveillance. Whether the effects of using machine learning are positive or negative depends on how and for which purpose the technology is applied. Therefore, specific health financing guidance and regulations, particularly for (voluntary) health insurance, are needed. To inform the development of specific health financing guidance and regulation, we propose several key policy and research questions. To gain a better understanding of how machine learning affects health financing for UHC objectives, more systematic and rigorous research should accompany the application of machine learning.
机器学习在卫生筹资功能(筹资、统筹和采购)中的应用日益增多,但缺乏其对全民健康覆盖(UHC)目标影响的证据。本文概述了机器学习的用例及其潜在的益处和风险。评估结果表明,机器学习在卫生筹资方面的各种用例有可能影响 UHC 的所有中期目标,包括资源分配的公平性(积极和消极两方面)、效率(主要是积极方面)和透明度(积极和消极两方面)。对 UHC 的所有三个最终目标,即根据需要利用卫生服务、财务保护和优质护理,也有积极和消极的影响。当机器学习的使用促进或简化了对 UHC 目标不利的卫生筹资任务时,就会存在各种风险,例如风险选择、以牺牲优质护理为代价的成本降低、财务保护降低或过度监管。使用机器学习的效果是积极的还是消极的,取决于技术的应用方式和目的。因此,需要特定的卫生筹资指导和监管,特别是针对(自愿)健康保险。为了为特定的卫生筹资指导和监管的制定提供信息,我们提出了几个关键的政策和研究问题。为了更好地了解机器学习如何影响实现 UHC 目标的卫生筹资,应在应用机器学习的同时进行更系统和严格的研究。