Department of Communication Sciences and Disorders, University of Cincinnati, OH.
Department of Speech-Language Pathology, University of Toronto, Ontario, Canada.
Am J Speech Lang Pathol. 2024 Jul 3;33(4):1698-1717. doi: 10.1044/2024_AJSLP-23-00164. Epub 2024 Apr 4.
The purpose of this study was to characterize the communicative participation and functional speech intelligibility (i.e., how children use communication and how well they are understood across everyday life) of typically developing (TD) bilingual Jamaican preschoolers and those with functionally defined speech sound disorders (fSSDs) in the COVID-19 milieu. Findings were also compared to an existing corpus of baseline data to document and explore differences in children's speech-language outcomes secondary to pandemic-related social restrictions.
Thirty bilingual Jamaican preschoolers, 21 TD and nine with fSSDs, were assessed during the pandemic via telepractice. Association and univariate mean testing were completed to characterize children's communicative participation and functional speech intelligibility. Data were then compared to an existing corpus of baseline data (collected in person between 2013 and 2019), which included direct child assessment and parent reports and consisted of TD ( = 226) Jamaican Creole-English-speaking preschoolers and those with fSSDs ( = 39) to compare performance profiles across data sets. All participants attended schools in Kingston, Jamaica.
Measures of communicative participation remained stable in the context of the COVID-19 milieu for children in the TD and fSSD groups, but functional speech intelligibility outcomes for children with fSSDs deviated between in-person findings collected from children pre-pandemic. Between-groups differences were also found on measures of speech production accuracy but were no longer significant when considering telepractice as a covariate.
Findings from this investigation serve to characterize the communicative participation and functional speech intelligibility of TD bilingual Jamaican preschoolers and those with fSSDs in the COVID-19 milieu. By extension, the results comparing data from preschoolers collected during the pandemic to an existing corpus of baseline data from a different group of preschoolers provide critical insights about multilingual children's speech-language outcomes in the context of acutely changing environmental circumstances.
本研究旨在描述在 COVID-19 大流行背景下,发育正常的(TD)双语牙买加学龄前儿童和有功能性语音障碍(fSSD)的儿童的交际参与度和功能性言语可理解度(即儿童在日常生活中使用沟通的方式和他们被理解的程度)。研究结果还与现有的基线数据进行了比较,以记录和探索由于大流行相关的社会限制对儿童言语语言结果的影响。
30 名双语牙买加学龄前儿童,21 名 TD 儿童和 9 名 fSSD 儿童,在大流行期间通过远程实践进行评估。完成关联和单变量均值检验,以描述儿童的交际参与度和功能性言语可理解度。然后,将数据与现有的基线数据进行比较(2013 年至 2019 年期间亲自收集),该数据包括对儿童的直接评估和家长报告,包括发育正常的(=226)牙买加克里奥尔语-英语学龄前儿童和有 fSSD(=39)的儿童,以比较数据集之间的表现特征。所有参与者均来自牙买加金斯敦的学校。
在 COVID-19 大流行背景下,TD 组和 fSSD 组儿童的交际参与度保持稳定,但 fSSD 组儿童的功能性言语可理解度结果与大流行前收集的儿童的现场发现不同。在言语产生准确性的测量上也发现了组间差异,但当考虑远程实践作为协变量时,这些差异不再显著。
本研究的结果有助于描述在 COVID-19 大流行背景下发育正常的双语牙买加学龄前儿童和有 fSSD 的儿童的交际参与度和功能性言语可理解度。通过扩展,将大流行期间收集的学龄前儿童数据与来自不同群组的学龄前儿童的现有基线数据进行比较的结果,为多语言儿童在环境急剧变化的情况下的言语语言结果提供了重要的见解。