Lyman Briggs College and Department of Sociology, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, United States of America.
Department of Media & Information, Michigan State University, East Lansing, MI, United States of America.
PLoS One. 2024 Apr 11;19(4):e0294735. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0294735. eCollection 2024.
Using a novel dataset of 590M messages by 21M users, we present the first large-scale examination of the behavior of likely Bernie supporters on Twitter during the 2020 U.S. Democratic primaries and presidential election. We use these data to dispel empirically the notion of a unified, stereotypical Bernie supporter (e.g., the "Bernie Bro"). Instead, our work uncovers significant variation in the identities and ideologies of Bernie supporters who were active on Twitter. Our work makes three contributions to the literature on social media and social movements. Methodologically, we present a novel mixed methods approach to surface identity and ideological variation within a movement via use of patterns in who retweets whom (i.e. who retweets which other users) and who retweets what (i.e. who retweets which specific tweets). Substantively, documentation of these variations challenges a trend in the social movement literature to assume actors within a particular movement are unified in their ideology, identity, and values.
利用一个包含 5.9 亿条消息和 2100 万用户的新颖数据集,我们首次大规模研究了 2020 年美国民主党初选和总统选举期间可能支持伯尼的用户在 Twitter 上的行为。我们使用这些数据从经验上驳斥了关于统一的、刻板的伯尼支持者(例如,“伯尼兄弟”)的观念。相反,我们的工作揭示了在 Twitter 上活跃的伯尼支持者在身份和意识形态方面的显著差异。我们的工作为社交媒体和社会运动文献做出了三项贡献。从方法论上讲,我们通过使用谁转发谁(即谁转发哪些其他用户)以及谁转发什么(即谁转发哪些特定推文)的模式,提出了一种新颖的混合方法来揭示运动内部的身份和意识形态差异。从实质上讲,这些变化的记录挑战了社会运动文献中的一种趋势,即假定特定运动中的参与者在其意识形态、身份和价值观方面是统一的。