ISPM, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland
ISPM, University of Bern, Bern, Switzerland.
BMJ Open. 2024 Apr 17;14(4):e084560. doi: 10.1136/bmjopen-2024-084560.
To compare vaccination willingness before rollout and 1 year post-rollout uptake among the general population and under-resourced communities in high-income countries.
A realist review.
Embase, PubMed, Dimensions ai and Google Scholar.
High-income countries.
We defined as the proportion of participants willing or intending to receive vaccines prior to availability. We defined vaccine uptake as the real proportion of the population with complete vaccination as reported by each country until November 2021.
We included data from 62 studies and 18 high-income countries. For studies conducted among general populations, the proportion of vaccination willingness was 67% (95% CI 62% to 72%). In real-world settings, the overall proportion of vaccine uptake among those countries was 73% (95% CI 69% to 76%). 17 studies reported pre-rollout willingness for under-resourced communities. The summary proportion of vaccination willingness from studies reporting results among people from under-resourced communities was 52% (95% CI 0.46% to 0.57%). Real-world evidence about vaccine uptake after rollout among under-resourced communities was limited.
Our review emphasises the importance of realist reviews for assessing vaccine acceptance. Limited real-world evidence about vaccine uptake among under-resourced communities in high-income countries is a call to context-specific actions and reporting.
比较高收入国家普通人群和资源匮乏社区在疫苗推出前的接种意愿和推出后 1 年的接种率。
现实主义综述。
Embase、PubMed、Dimensions ai 和 Google Scholar。
高收入国家。
我们将 定义为在疫苗供应之前愿意或打算接受疫苗的参与者比例。我们将疫苗接种率定义为截至 2021 年 11 月每个国家报告的完全接种疫苗的实际人口比例。
我们纳入了 62 项研究和 18 个高收入国家的数据。对于在普通人群中进行的研究,接种意愿的比例为 67%(95%置信区间 62%至 72%)。在实际环境中,这些国家的总体疫苗接种率为 73%(95%置信区间 69%至 76%)。17 项研究报告了资源匮乏社区的疫苗推出前意愿。报告资源匮乏社区人群结果的研究中,接种意愿的综合比例为 52%(95%置信区间 0.46%至 0.57%)。关于资源匮乏社区推出后疫苗接种情况的真实世界证据有限。
我们的综述强调了现实主义综述在评估疫苗接受度方面的重要性。高收入国家资源匮乏社区疫苗接种情况的真实世界证据有限,这呼吁采取具体的、有针对性的行动和报告。