Borrelli Sara, Ramasamy Renuka, Wong Ruth, Spiby Helen
Associate Professor in Midwifery, Research Assistant, Professor in Midwifery, University of Nottingham, School of Health Sciences, Queen's Medical School, B Floor, NG7 2UH, Nottingham, United Kingdom.
Information Specialist, University of Sheffield, School of Health and Related Research, Regent Court (ScHARR), 30 Regent Street, Sheffield, 1026AS1 4DA.
Int J Nurs Stud Adv. 2023 Jun 29;5:100139. doi: 10.1016/j.ijnsa.2023.100139. eCollection 2023 Dec.
Modern slavery is a largely hidden crime disproportionately affecting women and girls, with 71% of the world's enslaved people being female and approximately one third estimated to be pregnant. Healthcare professionals experience difficulties in caring for mothers affected by modern slavery, including asking appropriate questions and initiating discussions, making safe referrals, being uncertain about entitlements, and facing obstacles in accessing language support and specialist mental health services. Despite the expectation of cohesive and consistent services, which avoid the recounting of experiences that may re-traumatise, interdisciplinary collaborations between maternity services and non-statutory agencies remain unclear.
To map the available evidence and resources on maternity care provision and non-statutory support to pregnant women and mothers affected by modern slavery.
A scoping review was conducted following the JBI methodology for scoping reviews.
Five databases (Applied Social Sciences Index & Abstracts, Cumulated Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, Dissertations & Thesis A&I, Embase, Scopus) were searched. Inclusion criteria: English language; published between 2012 and May 2022; related to both maternity care provision and modern slavery; cross-sectional perspectives, including survivor mothers, healthcare professionals, midwives, and non-statutory service staff; any methodology. Exclusion criteria: general healthcare or not maternity related; opinion pieces, letters, book reviews, commentaries. Grey literature was searched using relevant websites reporting theses, blogs, policies, guidelines, and resources.
Twelve articles reporting 11 studies and 29 grey literature reports were retained for the scoping review. Three key themes were identified from research studies: women's perspectives on barriers to access and engagement with maternity services; challenges and needs identified by healthcare professionals; and the impact of human trafficking on maternal and neonatal outcomes. The grey literature resources comprised mainly blogs, information sheets, leaflets or webpages, and research or consultation reports. Maternity was being experienced by survivor mothers with the following: unfamiliarity with and lack of access to systems and information across all sectors, barriers to care and entitlements, contemporary threats of violence from partners/traffickers, restricted ability to move freely, issues related to traumatisation, dispersal policies, and dealing with multiple new systems.
Although several sources indicate principles that should be adopted, the detail of optimal care and support during maternity should be provided by healthcare professionals and non-statutory service staff is lacking. Further research is required, from which recommendations for good maternity practice and the effective intersection between statutory and non-statutory services can be derived and subsequently mobilised across different systems and settings.
现代奴隶制是一种很大程度上隐匿的犯罪行为,对妇女和女童的影响尤为严重,全球被奴役人口中有71%为女性,估计约三分之一处于怀孕状态。医疗保健专业人员在照料受现代奴隶制影响的母亲时面临困难,包括提出恰当问题并展开讨论、进行安全的转诊、对权利不确定,以及在获取语言支持和专业心理健康服务方面面临障碍。尽管期望提供连贯一致的服务,避免重述可能再次造成创伤的经历,但产科服务与非法定机构之间的跨学科合作仍不明确。
梳理关于为受现代奴隶制影响的孕妇及母亲提供产科护理和非法定支持的现有证据及资源。
按照循证卫生保健国际协作组织(JBI)的范围综述方法开展范围综述。
检索了五个数据库(应用社会科学索引与摘要数据库、护理及相关健康文献累积索引数据库、学位论文数据库、荷兰医学文摘数据库、Scopus数据库)。纳入标准:英文文献;2012年至2022年5月期间发表;与产科护理提供及现代奴隶制均相关;横断面研究视角,包括母亲幸存者、医疗保健专业人员、助产士及非法定服务人员;任何方法学类型。排除标准:一般医疗保健或与产科无关;观点文章、信函、书评、评论。使用相关网站检索灰色文献(报告论文、博客、政策、指南及资源)。
十二篇报告11项研究的文章及29份灰色文献报告被纳入范围综述。从研究中确定了三个关键主题:妇女对获得产科服务及参与产科服务的障碍的看法;医疗保健专业人员确定的挑战及需求;人口贩运对孕产妇和新生儿结局的影响。灰色文献资源主要包括博客、情况说明书、传单或网页,以及研究或咨询报告。母亲幸存者经历产科过程时面临以下情况:对所有部门的系统和信息不熟悉且难以获取,护理和权利方面的障碍,来自伴侣/贩运者的当代暴力威胁,行动自由受限,与创伤相关的问题,分散政策,以及应对多个新系统。
尽管有若干资料表明了应采用的原则,但缺乏医疗保健专业人员应提供的产科最佳护理和支持的详细信息,非法定服务人员也有所欠缺。需要进一步开展研究,从中得出有关良好产科实践以及法定和非法定服务有效交叉的建议,并随后在不同系统和环境中加以运用。