Stanford Graduate School of Education, Palo Alto, CA 94305.
University of Brasília, Brasília 70910-900, Brazil.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A. 2024 May 28;121(22):e2316300121. doi: 10.1073/pnas.2316300121. Epub 2024 May 21.
The transition to remote learning in the context of COVID-19 led to dramatic setbacks in education. Is the return to in-person classes to eliminate these losses eventually? We study this question using data from the of secondary students in São Paulo State, Brazil. We estimate the causal medium-run impacts of the length of exposure to remote learning during the pandemic through a triple-differences strategy, which contrasts changes in educational outcomes across municipalities and grades that resumed in-person classes earlier (already by Q4/2020) or only in 2021. We find that relative learning losses from longer exposure to remote learning did fade out over time-attesting that school reopening was at the same time key but not enough to mitigate accumulated learning losses in face of persistence. Using observational and experimental variation in local responses across 645 municipalities, we further document that remedial educational policies in the aftermath of the pandemic boosted learning recovery.
在 COVID-19 背景下向远程学习的转变导致了教育的重大挫折。最终是否要恢复面授课程以消除这些损失?我们使用巴西圣保罗州中学生的数据来研究这个问题。我们通过三重差分策略估计了疫情期间远程学习暴露时间长短对中期教育成果的因果影响,该策略对比了在更早(已经在 2020 年第四季度)或仅在 2021 年恢复面授课程的城市和年级的教育成果变化。我们发现,相对于远程学习时间较长的学生来说,学习损失逐渐消失,这表明学校重新开放在缓解学习损失方面是关键的,但并不是唯一的因素,因为在持续的情况下,学习损失仍然存在。我们还利用 645 个城市的局部反应的观测和实验变化进一步证明,疫情后的补救教育政策促进了学习的恢复。