Bradley Denae L, Kramer Camille T, Sufrin Carolyn B, Scott Karen A, Hayes Crystal M
Department of Sociology and Criminology, Howard University, Washington, DC, USA.
Department of Gynecology and Obstetrics, Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine, Baltimore, MD, USA.
J Racial Ethn Health Disparities. 2024 Jun 11. doi: 10.1007/s40615-024-02042-9.
Racism pervades the US criminal legal and family policing systems, particularly impacting cases involving women with a history of a substance use disorder (SUD). Laws criminalizing SUD during pregnancy disproportionately harm Black women, as do family policing policies around family separation. Discrimination within intersecting systems may deter Black pregnant women with a SUD from seeking evidence-based pregnancy and substance use care. This convergent parallel mixed-methods study aimed to illuminate how systemic oppression influenced the lived experiences of Black mothers with a SUD, facing dual involvement in the criminal legal and family policing systems. Using convenience and snowball sampling techniques, we recruited 15 Black mothers who were incarcerated, used substances while pregnant, and had a history with family policing systems. We conducted semi-structured interviews and developed and distributed a scale questionnaire to describe participants' experiences navigating overlapping systems of surveillance and control. Drawing on models of systemic anti-Black racism and sexism and reproductive justice, we assessed participants' experiences of racism and gender-based violence within these oppressive systems. Participants described how intersecting systems of surveillance and control impeded their prenatal care, recovery, and abilities to parent their children in gender and racially specific ways. Although they mostly detailed experiences of interpersonal discriminatory treatment, particularly from custody staff while incarcerated and pregnant, participants highlighted instances of systemic anti-Black gendered racism and obstetric racism while accessing prenatal care and substance use treatment in carceral and community settings. Their narratives emphasize the need for action to measure and address the upstream macro-level systems perpetuating inequities.
种族主义在美国刑事法律和家庭监管系统中普遍存在,尤其对涉及有物质使用障碍(SUD)病史女性的案件产生影响。将孕期物质使用障碍定为犯罪的法律对黑人女性造成了不成比例的伤害,家庭分离方面的家庭监管政策也是如此。交叉系统中的歧视可能会阻碍有物质使用障碍的黑人孕妇寻求基于证据的孕期和物质使用护理。这项融合平行混合方法研究旨在阐明系统性压迫如何影响有物质使用障碍的黑人母亲的生活经历,她们同时受到刑事法律和家庭监管系统的双重影响。我们采用便利抽样和滚雪球抽样技术,招募了15名黑人母亲,她们曾被监禁,孕期使用过毒品,并且有过与家庭监管系统打交道的经历。我们进行了半结构化访谈,并编制和分发了一份量表问卷,以描述参与者在重叠的监视和控制系统中的经历。借鉴系统性反黑人种族主义和性别歧视以及生殖正义的模式,我们评估了参与者在这些压迫性系统中遭受种族主义和基于性别的暴力的经历。参与者描述了监视和控制系统的交叉如何阻碍她们获得产前护理、康复,以及以符合性别和种族特点的方式养育子女的能力。尽管她们大多详细讲述了人际歧视性待遇的经历,特别是在被监禁和怀孕时受到监管人员的歧视,但参与者强调了在监狱和社区环境中接受产前护理和物质使用治疗时,系统性反黑人性别化种族主义和产科种族主义的实例。她们的叙述强调需要采取行动,衡量和解决导致不平等持续存在的上游宏观层面系统问题。