Department of Epidemiology and Health Monitoring, Robert Koch Institute, Berlin, Germany.
Faculty of Health Sciences, Department of Healthcare Management, Ankara University, Ankara, Türkiye.
Front Public Health. 2024 Jun 6;12:1378229. doi: 10.3389/fpubh.2024.1378229. eCollection 2024.
Between 2021 and 2023, a project was funded in order to explore the mortality burden (YLL-Years of Life Lost, excess mortality) of COVID-19 in Southern and Eastern Europe, and Central Asia.
For each national or sub-national region, data on COVID-19 deaths and population data were collected for the period March 2020 to December 2021. Unstandardized and age-standardised YLL rates were calculated according to standard burden of disease methodology. In addition, all-cause mortality data for the period 2015-2019 were collected and used as a baseline to estimate excess mortality in each national or sub-national region in the years 2020 and 2021.
On average, 15-30 years of life were lost per death in the various countries and regions. Generally, YLL rates per 100,000 were higher in countries and regions in Southern and Eastern Europe compared to Central Asia. However, there were differences in how countries and regions defined and counted COVID-19 deaths. In most countries and sub-national regions, YLL rates per 100,000 (both age-standardised and unstandardized) were higher in 2021 compared to 2020, and higher amongst men compared to women. Some countries showed high excess mortality rates, suggesting under-diagnosis or under-reporting of COVID-19 deaths, and/or relatively large numbers of deaths due to indirect effects of the pandemic.
Our results suggest that the COVID-19 mortality burden was greater in many countries and regions in Southern and Eastern Europe compared to Central Asia. However, heterogeneity in the data (differences in the definitions and counting of COVID-19 deaths) may have influenced our results. Understanding possible reasons for the differences was difficult, as many factors are likely to play a role (e.g., differences in the extent of public health and social measures to control the spread of COVID-19, differences in testing strategies and/or vaccination rates). Future cross-country analyses should try to develop structured approaches in an attempt to understand the relative importance of such factors. Furthermore, in order to improve the robustness and comparability of burden of disease indicators, efforts should be made to harmonise case definitions and reporting for COVID-19 deaths across countries.
2021 年至 2023 年期间,有一个项目获得了资金支持,旨在探索 COVID-19 在南欧和东欧以及中亚地区的死亡负担(YLL-寿命损失年数,超额死亡)。
对于每个国家或次国家地区,收集了 2020 年 3 月至 2021 年 12 月期间 COVID-19 死亡人数和人口数据。根据疾病负担标准方法计算了未标准化和年龄标准化的 YLL 率。此外,收集了 2015-2019 年期间的全因死亡率数据,并将其用作估计每个国家或次国家地区 2020 年和 2021 年超额死亡率的基线。
平均而言,各个国家和地区每例死亡损失 15-30 年的寿命。一般来说,南欧和东欧国家和地区的每 10 万人 YLL 率高于中亚地区。然而,各国和地区对 COVID-19 死亡的定义和计数存在差异。在大多数国家和次国家地区,2021 年每 10 万人的 YLL 率(标准化和未标准化)均高于 2020 年,男性高于女性。一些国家显示出高的超额死亡率,表明 COVID-19 死亡的漏报或漏诊,以及/或大流行的间接影响导致的相对大量死亡。
我们的研究结果表明,与中亚相比,南欧和东欧的许多国家和地区的 COVID-19 死亡负担更大。然而,数据的异质性(COVID-19 死亡的定义和计数差异)可能影响了我们的结果。由于许多因素可能发挥作用(例如,控制 COVID-19 传播的公共卫生和社会措施的程度不同、检测策略和/或疫苗接种率的差异),因此难以理解差异的可能原因。未来的跨国分析应尝试制定结构化方法,以试图了解这些因素的相对重要性。此外,为了提高疾病负担指标的稳健性和可比性,应努力协调各国 COVID-19 死亡的病例定义和报告。