Boghossian Nansi S, Greenberg Lucy T, Lorch Scott A, Phibbs Ciaran S, Buzas Jeffrey S, Passarella Molly, Saade George R, Rogowski Jeannette
Department of Epidemiology and Biostatistics, Arnold School of Public Health, University of South Carolina, Columbia, SC (Dr Boghossian).
Vermont Oxford Network, Burlington, VT (Ms Greenberg).
Am J Obstet Gynecol MFM. 2024 Aug;6(8):101412. doi: 10.1016/j.ajogmf.2024.101412. Epub 2024 Jun 21.
Previous studies examining racial and ethnic disparities in severe maternal morbidity (SMM) have mainly focused on intrapartum hospitalization. There is limited information regarding the racial and ethnic distribution of SMM occurring in the antepartum and postpartum periods, including SMM occurring beyond the traditional 6 weeks postpartum period.
To examine the racial and ethnic distribution of SMM during antepartum, intrapartum, and postpartum hospitalizations through 1-year postpartum, overall and stratified by maternal sociodemographic factors, and to estimate the percent increase in SMM by race and ethnicity and maternal sociodemographic factors within each racial and ethnic group after accounting for both antepartum and postpartum SMM through 1-year postpartum rather than just SMM occurring during the intrapartum hospitalization.
We conducted a retrospective cohort study using birth and fetal death certificate data linked to hospital discharge records from Michigan, Oregon, and South Carolina from 2008-2020. We examined the distribution of non-transfusion SMM and total SMM per 10,000 cases during antepartum, intrapartum, and postpartum hospitalizations through 365 days postpartum by race and ethnicity and by maternal education and insurance type within each racial and ethnic group. We subsequently examined "SMM cases added" by race and ethnicity and by maternal education and insurance type within each racial and ethnic group. The "SMM cases added" represent cases among unique individuals that are identified by considering the antepartum and postpartum periods but that would be missed if only the intrapartum hospitalization cases were included.
Among 2,584,206 birthing individuals, a total of 37,112 (1.4%) individuals experienced non-transfusion SMM and 64,661 (2.5%) experienced any SMM during antepartum, intrapartum, and/or postpartum hospitalization. Black individuals had the highest rate of antepartum, intrapartum, and postpartum non-transfusion and total SMM followed by American Indian individuals. Asian individuals had the lowest rate of non-transfusion and total SMM during antepartum and postpartum hospitalizations while White individuals had the lowest rate of non-transfusion and total SMM during the intrapartum hospitalization. Black individuals were 1.9 times more likely to experience non-transfusion SMM during the intrapartum hospitalization than White individuals, which increased to 2.8 times during the antepartum period and to 2.5 times during the postpartum period. Asian and Hispanic individuals were less likely to experience SMM in the postpartum period than White individuals. Including antepartum and postpartum hospitalizations resulted in disproportionately more cases among Black and American Indian individuals than among White, Hispanic, and Asian individuals. The additional cases were also more likely to occur among individuals with lower educational levels and individuals on government insurance.
Racial disparities in SMM are underreported in estimates that focus on the intrapartum hospitalization. Additionally, individuals with low socio-economic status bear the greatest burden of SMM occurring during the antepartum and postpartum periods. Approaches that focus on mitigating SMM during the intrapartum period only do not address the full spectrum of health disparities. El resumen está disponible en Español al final del artículo.
以往关于严重孕产妇发病(SMM)种族和民族差异的研究主要集中在分娩期住院。关于产前和产后期间发生的SMM的种族和民族分布的信息有限,包括传统产后6周以后发生的SMM。
研究产前、分娩期和产后住院至产后1年期间SMM的种族和民族分布,总体情况以及按孕产妇社会人口学因素分层的情况,并估计在考虑产前和产后至产后1年期间的SMM而非仅分娩期住院期间发生的SMM后,每个种族和民族群体内SMM因种族、民族和孕产妇社会人口学因素而增加的百分比。
我们进行了一项回顾性队列研究,使用了2008年至2020年密歇根州、俄勒冈州和南卡罗来纳州与医院出院记录相关联的出生和胎儿死亡证明数据。我们按种族和民族以及每个种族和民族群体内的孕产妇教育程度和保险类型,研究了产后365天内产前、分娩期和产后住院期间每10000例中的非输血性SMM和总SMM的分布情况。随后,我们按种族和民族以及每个种族和民族群体内的孕产妇教育程度和保险类型,研究了“新增SMM病例”。“新增SMM病例”指的是通过考虑产前和产后期间而识别出的独特个体中的病例,但如果仅包括分娩期住院病例则会遗漏这些病例。
在2584206名分娩个体中,共有37112名(1.4%)个体经历了非输血性SMM,64661名(2.5%)个体在产前、分娩期和/或产后住院期间经历了任何SMM。黑人个体的产前、分娩期和产后非输血性和总SMM发生率最高,其次是美洲印第安人个体。亚洲个体在产前和产后住院期间的非输血性和总SMM发生率最低,而白人个体在分娩期住院期间的非输血性和总SMM发生率最低。黑人个体在分娩期住院期间经历非输血性SMM的可能性是白人个体的1.9倍,在产前期间增加到2.8倍,在产后期间增加到2.5倍。亚洲和西班牙裔个体在产后期间经历SMM的可能性低于白人个体。包括产前和产后住院导致黑人及美洲印第安人个体中的病例比例相较于白人、西班牙裔和亚洲个体不成比例地更多。新增病例也更有可能发生在教育水平较低的个体和参加政府保险的个体中。
在关注分娩期住院的估计中,SMM的种族差异报告不足。此外,社会经济地位低的个体在产前和产后期间承担着SMM的最大负担。仅关注减轻分娩期SMM的方法无法解决全部的健康差异问题。文章末尾提供了西班牙语摘要。