Nazari Ahmed, Rajesh Mariya, Antoun Ibrahim, Mohamed Azhar Mohamed Sheeraz, Hayat Muhammad
Internal Medicine, Northampton General Hospital NHS Trust, Northampton, GBR.
Internal Medicine, Northampton General Hospital, Northampton, GBR.
Cureus. 2024 May 24;16(5):e60976. doi: 10.7759/cureus.60976. eCollection 2024 May.
Introduction Oral presentation and public speaking skills are poorly emphasised in the medical school curriculum. The student grand round was created to tackle this deficiency by changing the way in which students are taught, from traditional lecture-based learning to interactive small-group peer-to-peer teaching. This approach encourages students to become responsible for their own learning, develop their public speaking and teaching skills, as well as identify and address gaps in their knowledge. Aims The primary aims of this study were to determine the understanding of students before and after peer teaching, including retention of concepts via quiz scores and confidence of students in giving SBAR (Situation, Background, Assessment, Recommendation) handovers. The secondary aim is to determine the place of student-led grand round teaching in the medical curriculum as a means of developing teaching skills and encouraging active learning. Methods A cohort of 21 third-year medical students from Leicester University attended a weekly peer teaching programme where students presented a case they had encountered during their clinical attachment. Peer teachers were required to research some background and pathophysiology regarding the topic and teach in an interactive manner and create discussion regarding the topic. The students then summarised the case and practised the skill of concise handovers using the SBAR format. Knowledge and understanding were assessed with an interactive quiz, and feedback via a survey was gathered before and after sessions. Each student engaged in case discussion and received input from a specialty registrar regarding their presentation skills, case knowledge, and SBAR handover. Results Individual and combined session analysis demonstrated a significant improvement in scores across understanding the topic and confidence in SBAR. Student recommendation for the session cumulatively was significant (p=0.02); however, comparison of medical student recommendations of individual sessions did not yield statistically significant results. There was a significant improvement in the overall quiz score (p=0.045), and average scores improved from 51% to 70% (p=0.043). There was a significant increase in the mean quiz result after the first two sessions (28-55% (p=0.002) and 56-85% (p=0.0001), respectively). Summary The student grand round is a promising teaching initiative that capitalises on peer teaching, a valuable learning theory that centres around students taking on the role of teachers to instruct their peers. Results from this study have shown that this method of collaborative teaching is effective in improving the understanding of medical topics, increases confidence in public speaking and precise handover skills, and therefore better prepares medical students for their career as future clinicians.
引言 在医学院课程中,口头报告和公众演讲技能未得到充分重视。学生大查房的设立旨在解决这一不足,它改变了学生的教学方式,从传统的基于讲座的学习转变为互动式小组同伴教学。这种方法鼓励学生对自己的学习负责,培养他们的公众演讲和教学技能,以及识别和弥补知识差距。
目的 本研究的主要目的是确定同伴教学前后学生的理解情况,包括通过测验分数评估概念的掌握程度以及学生在进行SBAR(情况、背景、评估、建议)交接时的信心。次要目的是确定学生主导的大查房教学在医学课程中的地位,作为培养教学技能和鼓励主动学习的一种方式。
方法 来自莱斯特大学的21名三年级医学生参加了每周一次的同伴教学项目,学生们展示他们在临床实习中遇到的病例。同伴教师需要研究该主题的一些背景和病理生理学知识,并以互动方式进行教学,引发关于该主题的讨论。然后学生们总结病例,并使用SBAR格式练习简洁交接的技能。通过互动测验评估知识和理解情况,并在课程前后通过调查收集反馈。每个学生参与病例讨论,并从专科住院医师那里获得关于他们演讲技巧、病例知识和SBAR交接的意见。
结果 对单个课程和综合课程的分析表明,在对主题的理解和SBAR方面的信心得分有显著提高。学生对课程的总体推荐具有统计学意义(p = 0.02);然而,对单个课程的医学生推荐进行比较未得出具有统计学意义的结果。总体测验分数有显著提高(p = 0.045),平均分数从51%提高到70%(p = 0.043)。在前两节课之后,平均测验结果有显著提高(分别从28%提高到55%(p = 0.002)和从56%提高到85%(p = 0.0001))。
总结 学生大查房是一项很有前景的教学举措,它利用了同伴教学这一有价值的学习理论,该理论围绕学生扮演教师角色指导同伴展开。本研究结果表明,这种合作教学方法在提高对医学主题的理解、增强公众演讲信心和精确交接技能方面是有效的,因此能更好地让医学生为未来临床医生的职业生涯做好准备。