EHESP French School of Public Health, Paris, France; Institut Pasteur, Paris, France.
Research Group for the Prevention of Occupational Infections in Healthcare Workers (GERES), Paris, France.
Vaccine. 2024 Oct 24;42(24):126103. doi: 10.1016/j.vaccine.2024.07.004. Epub 2024 Jul 6.
Across various stages of the COVID-19 pandemic and related vaccine recommendations in France, we assessed the association of the 7C-psychological antecedents with vaccine uptake/intention for booster vaccination among healthcare-sector workers (HCSWs). We also assessed whether 7C-antecedent profiles changed over time.
The Research Group for the Prevention of Occupational Infections in Healthcare Workers (GERES) conducted three repeated web-surveys which were disseminated by email chain-referral among HCSWs throughout France. The questionnaires waves took place: July-November 2021, February-March 2022 and January-March 2023 (P2, P3 and P4). We also reanalysed data from a prior similar study conducted late 2020-early 2021 (Moirangthem et al. (2022)) (P1). To evaluate the association of 7C-items with vaccine uptake-intention for future vaccination, we estimated adjusted prevalence ratios (aPR) using robust variance Poisson regression. We report the 7C-item population attributable loss in vaccine intention.
The four surveys (P1-P4) encompassed 5234, 339, 351 and 437 participants. At earlier stages of the vaccine campaign, the principal antecedents of vaccine intention were favorable perception of vaccination benefit-risk-balance (BRB) (vs. unfavorable, aPR: 2.32), reactance to employer encouragement for vaccination (motivates vs. dissuades-me, aPR:2.23), vaccine confidence (vs. not-being-confident, aPR: 1.71) and social conformism towards vaccination (favorable vs. skeptical opinion in private environment, aPR: 1.33). Under a vaccine mandate for HCSWs, only perceiving vaccination as a collective action was associated with current vaccine status (agree vs. disagree, aPR: 2.19). At later stages of the epidemic, hypothetical booster vaccine intentions were strongly associated with BRB perception (favorable vs. unfavorable, aPR: 2.07) and perceiving vaccination as a collective action (agree vs. disagree, aPR: 1.69). Fearing a severe side effect from vaccination decreased population vaccine intention by 26.2 %.
Our results suggest that both 7C-antecedents and their association with vaccine behaviour can change over time, and underscore the importance of assuring confidence in vaccine safety.
在 COVID-19 大流行的各个阶段以及法国相关疫苗建议中,我们评估了 7C 心理前因与医疗保健工作者(HCSWs)加强针疫苗接种意愿/接种率之间的关联。我们还评估了 7C 前因特征是否随时间发生变化。
预防医疗保健工作者职业感染研究小组(GERES)进行了三次重复的网络调查,通过电子邮件链状推荐在法国各地的 HCSWs 中进行了问卷调查。问卷波分别于 2021 年 7 月至 11 月、2022 年 2 月至 3 月和 2023 年 1 月至 3 月(P2、P3 和 P4)进行。我们还重新分析了 2020 年末至 2021 年初进行的一项类似研究的数据(Moirangthem 等人,2022 年)(P1)。为了评估 7C 项目与未来疫苗接种意愿之间的关联,我们使用稳健方差泊松回归估计了调整后的患病率比(aPR)。我们报告了疫苗接种意愿的 7C 项目人群归因损失。
四项调查(P1-P4)共纳入了 5234、339、351 和 437 名参与者。在疫苗接种运动的早期阶段,疫苗接种意愿的主要前因是对疫苗益处-风险平衡的有利看法(与不利看法相比,aPR:2.32),对雇主鼓励接种疫苗的抵触情绪(激发 vs. 劝阻,aPR:2.23),疫苗信心(与不自信相比,aPR:1.71)和对疫苗的社会从众心理(在私人环境中持有利还是怀疑的意见,aPR:1.33)。在对 HCSWs 实施疫苗接种强制令后,只有将接种疫苗视为集体行动与当前疫苗接种状况相关(同意 vs. 不同意,aPR:2.19)。在大流行后期,假设的加强针疫苗接种意愿与 BRB 感知(有利 vs. 不利,aPR:2.07)和将接种疫苗视为集体行动(同意 vs. 不同意,aPR:1.69)密切相关。担心接种疫苗会产生严重副作用会使人群疫苗接种意愿降低 26.2%。
我们的研究结果表明,7C 前因及其与疫苗行为的关联都会随时间发生变化,这突显了确保疫苗安全性的重要性。